I think you should definitely get rid of Cleary, he could be out for 2-4 weeks, and if he is fit, is out for at least another 2 origins.
Just note that if Cleary is not playing origin, then Hynes definitely is playing. So a straight swap isn't necessarily the quick fix.
Dylan Brown did really well last night, so you can look into that, but if Moses comes back, that changes things.
SJ without getting injured is a safe choice as he's the dominant half and without actually winning or getting many tries/assists lately, is still getting like 50 points.