Shane Reti's office has admitted a chart referred to in press conference does not exist.
www.nzherald.co.nz
Shane Retiβs office admits chart used to justify $1.4b Health cuts βdoes not existβ
Thomas Coughlan
By Thomas Coughlan
Deputy Political EditorΒ·NZ HeraldΒ·
5 Sep, 2024 05:42 PM
4 mins to read
Save
Share
Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and Health Minster Dr Shane Reti announcing the appointment of a commissioner to Health NZ. Photo / Mark Mitchell
Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and Health Minster Dr Shane Reti announcing the appointment of a commissioner to Health NZ. Photo / Mark Mitchell
Health Minister Shane Retiβs office has admitted an organisational chart of Health NZ - Te Whatu Ora, which allegedly proved the organisation had become bloated and inefficient βdoes not existβ.
Reti used the chart to justify painful spending restraint at Health NZ. He now claims that there was not one organisational chart as initially claimed, but that he was referring to an amalgam of the many Health NZ organisational charts he had seen.
Labourβs health spokesperson Ayesha Verrall told the Herald the invented chart has made Prime Minister Christopher Luxon, who was standing beside Reti when he made the remarks, βlook like an idiotβ.
βThe claims made about Health NZ in July are made up and they used those claims to justify a commissioner and cuts of $1.4 billion to the health system,β she said.
Discover more
'Makes no sense': Health Minister queries hospital ...
Govt invests $30m to improve access to X-rays, CT scans ...
How the government's view of Health NZ did a 180ΒΊ in ...
Dr Shane Reti: MΔori Health Authority was a bureaucratic ...
Advertisement
Advertise with NZME.
In July, Reti took to the podium in the Beehive theatrette alongside Luxon to announce Health NZ - Te Whatu Ora was staring down the barrel of a $1.4b deficit thanks to a bloated, inefficient bureaucracy.
Make a beeline for the Beehive
Iβm not interested in Political Briefing newsletter. Please donβt show me this again.
The pair announced the Health NZ board had been sacked and Lester Levy had been appointed Commissioner to govern the organisation back to financial health.
To justify his claim of bloated bureaucracy, Luxon said there could be 14 layers of management between the CEO and the patient.
When asked what these layers were, Reti twice referred to a single organisational chart that demonstrated these layers.
Advertisement
Advertise with NZME.
βLook, thereβs an org chart which Iβve seen which is just mind-boggling. I could not name the different layers of wayfinders, pathfinders, boundary spanners - Lord knows what else - from A to B. I could not name them for you,β Reti said.
When asked whether he could send the chart to media to prove his claim, Reti said he would approach Levy βto send around the chart and the information we have on thatβ.
Later, officials did send media a list of 14 management layers. It showed that there were not 14 layers between the CEO and the patient, but 14 layers including the CEO and the patient.
The Herald requested the specific chat Reti had referred to in the press conference under the Official Information Act. The request was finally answered this week, with Retiβs office conceding: βIn response to your request, an organisational chart that covers the entirety of Health New Zealandβs structure does not existβ.
Labour's Health Spokeswoman Ayesha Verrall said the remarks had made the prime minister look like an idiot. Photo / Mark Mitchell.
Labour's Health Spokeswoman Ayesha Verrall said the remarks had made the prime minister look like an idiot. Photo / Mark Mitchell.
The office then attached the list of 14 job titles sent to other media.
The Herald asked Retiβs office whether he had been completely truthful when he had claimed to have seen the org chart which does not exist and when he had offered to ask Levy to send the nonexistent chart to media.
A spokesperson replied, βThere is no single organisational chart covering Health New Zealand, although there are several org charts of different formats covering different parts of the agency.
βThe point the minister made at post cab was focused on a number of ambiguous job titles in health which donβt clearly explain their purpose,β they said.
Verrall told the Herald she had herself asked for organisational charts from Health NZ using written Parliamentary questions. She had requested an organisational chart showing job titles and names of office holders down to tier three, meaning the chief executive, the executive leadership team, and their support staff.
This question was refused because it would have required Health NZ staff to undertake βa substantial manual collationβ.
Verrall said she was concerned that the Government had yet to conclusively prove the claims used to justify sacking Health NZβs board, inserting a commissioner, and beginning a savings exercise. This was concerning because with no board, Health NZ was no longer publishing board minutes which give an insight into how the organisation is performing.
βIt matters if those claims canβt be borne out. Thereβs no 14 layers of management, thereβs no organisational chart, the cost was not due to back-office start but due to nursing hiring. So much of what the Government built its case on has been shown to be untrue,β she said.
βNew Zealanders have a right to know if these cuts are justified. The Government has had one press conference and hasnβt made the case. It has asserted there are financial problems at Health NZ. They have not released any documents to show that is the case.β
Thomas Coughlan is Deputy Political Editor and covers politics from Parliament. He has worked for the Herald since 2021 and has worked in the press gallery since 2018.