I think the thought was we could never win the competition with unstructured
SJ at his significant cost (with
RTS also on huge $).
Don’t forget the years of us complaining we could never get an elite prop to provide a platform for
SJ - because the cap spend didn’t allow it!
He since evolved his game management, matured, and accepted less of the cap.
If we carried on our success, no one would have cared but disrupting the team when we didn’t perform any better left a sour taste.
I understood the logic at the time, even if it played out poorly and blew up on everyone.