I really dislike the "this is the same pack as last season" argument. We look 10x fitter than we did last season and everyone is just playing much better. Feels like a totally different beast. Now combine that fittness with a change in 6 again rules where for certain infringements beyond the 20-metre line, the tackle count will restart, replacing the current 40-metre threshold. Then you've got a recipe for exactly what happened in 2021 with the panthers and storm. Fit teams absolutly destorying unfit teams, making them look undeciplined as they fail to wrestle back any momentum.
This IMO has made boyd look like a super star. Because he is always given a chance to play into a very tried, frustrated team at some point. And when he does, he scores. Where he never really got that chance last year, as we never overpowered teams quite like we have this year. He has shown the capacity to do this even at the titans. And what else can you ask from him honestly. Sure he hasn't proven to win games when we aren't by far the fitter team in peak "Vlandysball" era. But he deserves the opptunity again to do so. If the other teams catch up to our level of fittness (outside of the panthers).
So even if i think metcalf is a better half. Boyd and CHT belong as our 7 and 6 until proven otherwise and metcalf can stay in NSW until an injury lets him back into the team. You simply cannot break up a spine that is not losing. Disruption needs to be keept to a minimum.