NRL NRL 2024 General Recruitment Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Highlights Only (1)
BigUCE said:
I would be looking at getting rid of Kennedy, moving Hynes to FB and re-signing Dan Atkinson to play in the halves with Trindall.
Click to expand...
Spot on. Paying Nicho so much to play second fiddle to Trindall at 6 is rough.
Much better to stick him at FB where he can have much more impact.
I’m worried about Nicho though, he looked so bad at the end of the year.
Fitzgibbon must be worried as well with the much cap space taken up.
 
19 MINUTES AGO
#239,435
Juice
Well-known member
Does anyone know or listen to the hello sport podcast & have any idea if they have info? I seen they said Roosters want to trade Jazz Tevaga for May which seems completely ridiculous.

Jazz is the same type of style player as cheese (not saying he is anywhere near as good) who is out for half the season but can’t see it being true
 
Tevaga has a better attitude to Smith. On field though he probably gives away more penalties or has more unforced errors compared to Smith. I haven't looked at any stats just taken that from watching.

Smith when he is fit does do a lot work. His distribution could improve.

The trade talk is interesting. The NRL needs more buy in from the player compared to American sports. Tevaga is probably looking for properties in Manly to get settled. Hang on.

Mind you if the Roosters are after you as a player it is worth a look. The "off field" opportunities and contact you hear about would be good for life after footy. They are also competitive more often than not.
 
snake77 said:
Tevaga has a better attitude to Smith. On field though he probably gives away more penalties or has more unforced errors compared to Smith. I haven't looked at any stats just taken that from watching.

Smith when he is fit does do a lot work. His distribution could improve.

The trade talk is interesting. The NRL needs more buy in from the player compared to American sports. Tevaga is probably looking for properties in Manly to get settled. Hang on.

Mind you if the Roosters are after you as a player it is worth a look. The "off field" opportunities and contact you hear about would be good for life after footy. They are also competitive more often than not.
Click to expand...
If there’s any truth to that rumour I’d imagine Brandon Smith might have something lined up? I agree they’re similar players, especially with Samoa starting Jazz at hooker. Don’t think he’s going to be able to avoid hooker on his resume as much as he’s tried too before. Roosters have said that Smith won’t be extended past his current deal so I wonder he might link up with Ryles again at the eels?
 
The Warrior Waka said:
Man, I'd Trade Will Kennedy for Rts & CNK. Hella underrated.
Click to expand...

I know stats aren't everything, but man that's a difficult argument to justify. I've always been a fan of Kennedy though.
Most would agree that Charnz had a poor this year, but here are the stats (per game, not total as Kennedy played way more games than Charnz)

Tries - Charnz
Try assists - Even
Missed tackles - Charnz (less than Kennedy)
Like breaks - Charnz
Line break assists - Kennedy
Errors - Charnz - (less than Kennedy)
Meters gained - Charnz (almost double Kennedy)
Offloads - Charnz

That's only for this year, but yeah not even close despite Charnz being quite poor
 
Tookey 2.0 said:
I know stats aren't everything, but man that's a difficult argument to justify. I've always been a fan of Kennedy though.
Most would agree that Charnz had a poor this year, but here are the stats (per game, not total as Kennedy played way more games than Charnz)

Tries - Charnz
Try assists - Even
Missed tackles - Charnz (less than Kennedy)
Like breaks - Charnz
Line break assists - Kennedy
Errors - Charnz - (less than Kennedy)
Meters gained - Charnz (almost double Kennedy)
Offloads - Charnz

That's only for this year, but yeah not even close despite Charnz being quite poor
Click to expand...
I really like his speed. He's a underrated defender to. Not scared to put his body on the line.
I love Charnze. But to have Will's speed at the back would be mean. Otherwise, Cnk or rts will do i suppose 🤣
 
Tookey 2.0 said:
I know stats aren't everything, but man that's a difficult argument to justify. I've always been a fan of Kennedy though.
Most would agree that Charnz had a poor this year, but here are the stats (per game, not total as Kennedy played way more games than Charnz)

Tries - Charnz
Try assists - Even
Missed tackles - Charnz (less than Kennedy)
Like breaks - Charnz
Line break assists - Kennedy
Errors - Charnz - (less than Kennedy)
Meters gained - Charnz (almost double Kennedy)
Offloads - Charnz

That's only for this year, but yeah not even close despite Charnz being quite poor
Click to expand...
I have been worried about Charnze for several months.
It’s like he has lost his pace whilst not ever super quick was pretty decent.
Seems not to be moving as freely either.
Perhaps he should have rested rather than play for the Kiwis but you can’t blame a guy for wanting to rep the country.
Hope he comes right.
 
Noitall said:
If there’s any truth to that rumour I’d imagine Brandon Smith might have something lined up? I agree they’re similar players, especially with Samoa starting Jazz at hooker. Don’t think he’s going to be able to avoid hooker on his resume as much as he’s tried too before. Roosters have said that Smith won’t be extended past his current deal so I wonder he might link up with Ryles again at the eels?
Click to expand...
There has already been rumours/reports about the roosters not re-signing Brandon Smith. I wonder which clubs would take him. Maybe tigers or dragons?
 
Inruin said:
There has already been rumours/reports about the roosters not re-signing Brandon Smith. I wonder which clubs would take him. Maybe tigers or dragons?
Click to expand...
Dragons in talks with Atkinson at sharks, Gutherson, Brodie Croft and JAC. Their spine could potentially be
Gutherson
Atkinson
Croft
Liddle
They apparently going to play Cook at 13
 
Inruin said:
There has already been rumours/reports about the roosters not re-signing Brandon Smith. I wonder which clubs would take him. Maybe tigers or dragons?
Click to expand...
Tricky with Brandon Smith because he’s out for a good portion of next season injured. Eels chasing the knights Brailey hard apparently but wouldn’t be surprised to see Smith head there? Could see plenty of teams keen though, perhaps raiders
 
Ref said:
I have been worried about Charnze for several months.
It’s like he has lost his pace whilst not ever super quick was pretty decent.
Seems not to be moving as freely either.
Perhaps he should have rested rather than play for the Kiwis but you can’t blame a guy for wanting to rep the country.
Hope he comes right.
Click to expand...
Big drop in form from CNK, he wasn’t alone though. I wonder if the club could have told him he won’t be extended past his current deal? He hasn’t been one that the club seems to have prioritised
 
Classic how clubs now use the gentle push to offload a player with a year still to run, ‘we won’t be resigning you, after next year so you can move now if you get a deal’. … but we’d love you to stay 🤦🏽‍♂️
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

1995warriorsfan
  • Sticky
NRL NRL 2026 General Recruitment Thread
25 26 27
Replies
527
Views
37K
Noitall
  • Locked
NRL NRL 2025 General Recruitment Thread
146 147 148
Replies
3K
Views
270K
1995warriorsfan
1995warriorsfan
1995warriorsfan
NRL NRL ROUND 6 GENERAL DISCUSSION
10 11 12
Replies
230
Views
5K
CWC
CWC
1995warriorsfan
NRL NRL Round 10 2026 Discussion
Replies
10
Views
108
Naynay
1995warriorsfan
NRL NRL Round 9 2026 Discussion
16 17 18
Replies
345
Views
5K
CWC
CWC
Back
Top Bottom