Team List [2023, Finals Week 1] - Penrith Vs Warriors

vs

Kickoff In:

Thursday
Afternoon
12:00

Team Lists

 

🤖 Thread Summary

rugged #3435 kicked off the discussion by analyzing the 2018 Warriors versus Panthers finals clash, noting the impact of 40/20 kicks and DWZ's dominant performance for Penrith. The conversation quickly evolved into a comprehensive analysis of the upcoming finals matchup between the Warriors and Panthers. Playdaball #3154 shared rumors about SJ potentially being unavailable, sparking immediate debate among forum members about the halfback situation.

Aman 2.Aman 2.0 #3326 expressed frustration with referee Adam Gee's assignment to the game, arguing that the NRL favors a Broncos-Panthers finals scenario. The discussion revealed significant concern about the officiating crew, Bay39er #2851 confirming Gee as referee and Ashley Klein as Senior Review Official. Several members, sup42 #2855 shuffle #2857, predicted unfavorable officiating for the Warriors.

Team selection analysis dominated much of the discussion, particularly around Jazz Tevaga's inclusion over Bunty Afoa. Makasene #2974 questioned the bench composition, preferring more leg-drive impact from forwards. However, sup42 #2893 supported Jazz's selection, emphasizing his defensive capabilities and the psychological advantage of having the Walker twins together. MrFrankWhite #2975 interpreted the selection as Webby choosing the most mobile, up-tempo team possible to maintain high intensity for 80 minutes.

Strategic discussions emerged around how to defeat the Panthers, with multiple references to Parramatta's successful approach. sup42 #2945 highlighted Frank White's observation about the Eels surrendering in tackles to avoid Penrith's defensive advantages. The conversation also focused on the importance of limiting unforced errors and maintaining defensive pressure. Several members noted the Warriors' statistical advantages in certain areas, particularly in the forward pack matchups, while acknowledging Penrith's superiority in the centers.

NZWarriors.com

There’s no way he’s got a calf injury that would only keep him out one week. SJ likely won’t get too many more opportunities like this at the end of his career. He’s already got his contract sorted for next year. So you push through that shit and play.

I would say he’s done or it’s a multi week injury and they’ve said he’ll be available next week so ticket sales don’t fall off a cliff.

I would usually say the team is bigger than one person, but I think we’re close to being fucked here. Only because we have no one else with a semblance of kicking game, which is massively important in finals games. If Walker is moved to five eighth then I’ll chalk that up as a loss, if we can get Volkman in there somehow I give us a slight chance. Up the wahs regardless.
 
There’s no way he’s got a calf injury that would only keep him out one week. SJ likely won’t get too many more opportunities like this at the end of his career. He’s already got his contract sorted for next year. So you push through that shit and play.

I would say he’s done or it’s a multi week injury and they’ve said he’ll be available next week so ticket sales don’t fall off a cliff.

I would usually say the team is bigger than one person, but I think we’re close to being fucked here. Only because we have no one else with a semblance of kicking game, which is massively important in finals games. If Walker is moved to five eighth then I’ll chalk that up as a loss, if we can get Volkman in there somehow I give us a slight chance. Up the wahs regardless.
Volkman is the closest thing we have to a kicking game, i would rather him in a baptism of fire and be more ready for next weeks game at Mt Smart, it gives him three games in a row! He's been one of the better halves in cup, surely its him.
 
Volkman is the closest thing we have to a kicking game, i would rather him in a baptism of fire and be more ready for next weeks game at Mt Smart, it gives him three games in a row! He's been one of the better halves in cup, surely its him.
Not sure if it was talked about in the post match thread last week.

But the coaching staff had Volkman playing to the exact same kicking plan as they use with SJ. High and deep right, letting our right edge chase hard and pin them down.

Problem is Volkman doesn't have the same height or depth as SJ, so the kicks were landing short with the chase being not quite there as we've seen all season.

They will need to alter the plan if Volkman is to play on Saturday, because that didn't work against the Dolphins let alone Penrith.
 
Webby has talked about that "next man up" mentality all season, the next man up is Volkman. Get him in, and then it's on the rest of the team to do everything they can to make sure he has as much time as possible to make good decisions when he gets the ball. That means quick play the ball on the 5th, crisp service from dummy half and clear communication from the guys around him. Shifting guys out of their favored positions to fill SJ's spot makes no sense to me.
 
Back
Top Bottom