Lel.If they are doing productive jobs, even just doing jobs the councils or govt currently do, you could save money. Could be clearing bush for DOC; working for charities in food kitchens; extra set of hands as teacher aides in schools; etc. win/ win. And compliance would be minimal, don’t turn up don’t get paid
Cool so now you’ve distorted the work for hire market, the bush cutting businesses, hospitality workers. All for what? To penalise people so you can feel better.
The shallowness of the calculations always shows cost as a cover for punishments. Also again with the contradictions. You love claiming govts just waste, but then claim govt could run a labour hire company on top on administration and enforcement?!? Mate tell em they’re dreaming.
Next you have all the second order effects. What’s the school and health outcomes for kids with both parents committed this forced labour? How many generations to break the welfare cycle?
It might not be palatable but it’s the facts.