Politics 🗳️ NZ Politics

🤖 AI Summary

📝 Summary:

The thread centers on New Zealand's upcoming election, primarily debating the economic management and policy differences between the center-left Labour government and center-right National/ACT opposition. Key criticisms target Labour's fiscal stewardship, citing ballooning government expenditure #7#272, housing unaffordability, and unfulfilled promises like KiwiBuild and dental care expansion #16#12. A user #7 highlighted Labour's annual 9% spending growth versus 1.5% under previous governments, arguing this fueled inflation. National's tax-cut policy faced scrutiny over funding gaps and legality, with user #215 questioning Luxon's reliance on "trust me" assurances.
Leadership competence emerged as a critical theme, particularly in later posts. Luxon drew heavy criticism after a contentious interview where he struggled to defend policy details #194#199#211, while Willis faced backlash for her economic credentials. Hipkins garnered fleeting praise for articulation but was ultimately seen as representing poor governmental outcomes #45#119. A trusted user #308 presented expert economic analysis contradicting Treasury optimism. Infrastructure issues—like Wellington's water crisis and the dental school staffing shortage—were cited as examples of systemic mismanagement #235#12. Notable policy debates included road-user charges for EVs #220, immigration impacts on rents #299, and coalition scenarios involving NZ First #182#258. Early fringe discussions on candidates' rugby allegiances gave way to substantive policy critiques, culminating in grim Treasury forecasts discussed in posts #271#304#308. User #168 also revealed concerns about Labour rushing regulatory changes to entrench policies pre-election.

🏷️ Tags:

Economic Policies, Housing Crisis, Leadership Competence

📊 Data Source: Based on ALL posts in thread (total: 10000 posts) | ⏱️ Total Generation Time: 20s
You don't have permission to regenerate AI summary.
I’ll tell you what we all did vote on - getting cost of living back to reasonable levels. The disruption from these attacks on shipping lines & supply chain is potentially quite significant. In the last month global container freight rates have nearly tripled. That will fuel inflation if nothing is done.
Well, under labour it looks like the cost of living has come down. Fancy that. See one of my previous posts today.
 

NZWarriors.com

Well, under labour it looks like the cost of living has come down. Fancy that. See one of my previous posts today.
Seriously, the cost of living has come down? Please provide a link to that. I'm really interested to know what is cheaper now than this time last year that is making it easier on people. The same people withdrawing their kiwisaver in record numbers for hardship.
 
Isn’t it still terrorism if it’s political attacks in an independent country?

So devils advocate, you would support Palestinian supporters attacking shipping routes in NZ?

What’s the difference?
I think context is required. If we were seeing a lot more pressure from countries that had considerable power to influence and potentially stop the Gaza massacre I would be more inclined to condemn what the Houthi's are doing. But nothing is really happening, the biggest player in this conflict, the US, is actively arming Israel in it's Genocide of the Gaza populace.
 
Do you support or condemn the Houthi attacks irrespective of what’s happening in Israel/ Palestine?

Personally think they are unacceptable, destabilising and we should be doing all we can to ring-fence this and stop this spreading to the rest of the Middle East. This is happening 2,000km away in a completely different country…

I think you can do that while being neutral on the Israel/ Palestine conflict.

Given what happened on the Gazza Israel borders to kick all this shit off, I am wondering what your 'ring fencing' looks like?
 
Well, under labour it looks like the cost of living has come down. Fancy that. See one of my previous posts today.
"has come down" and "cost of living increasing" can coexist. E.g. prices rising but less sharply
Well, if anyone can make sense of that I'm impressed.

The cost of living has come down but is also increasing. That's some funny stuff right there.
 
Well, if anyone can make sense of that I'm impressed.

The cost of living has come down but is also increasing. That's some funny stuff right there.
If something cost 6 in 2020 and it cost 8 in 2021 that's an increase of 33%. In one year. Now many variables can happen, including a wage rise. Excluding that and keeping it simple, the inflation is reduced in the next year and the same object goes up from 8 to 9 that following year. An increase of 12.5% relative to 8, and an increase of 15.66% relative to 6.

The price still went up, but by less than the previous year.

So it's come down but is also increasing, relative.

1706073051213.webp
 
I think context is required. If we were seeing a lot more pressure from countries that had considerable power to influence and potentially stop the Gaza massacre I would be more inclined to condemn what the Houthi's are doing. But nothing is really happening, the biggest player in this conflict, the US, is actively arming Israel in it's Genocide of the Gaza populace.
To be fair, this is something I’m not particularly up with the historical and geopolitical context.

I can see your side and you seem to be more knowledgeable and passionate about the subject.

From an outsider I just think we need to stop it spreading or we face it spiralling into something a lot worse for everyone.
 
If something cost 6 in 2020 and it cost 8 in 2021 that's an increase of 33%. In one year. Now many variables can happen, including a wage rise. Excluding that and keeping it simple, the inflation is reduced in the next year and the same object goes up from 8 to 9 that following year. An increase of 12.5% relative to 8, and an increase of 15.66% relative to 6.

The price still went up, but by less than the previous year.

So it's come down but is also increasing, relative.

View attachment 4963
The big questions are which Labour policies domestically have pushed up inflation and which have decreased it to rate the govt?

I’ll start with a few, some directly linked to the property, rates and insurance costs:

Increased compliance costs on councils
Increased compliance costs on Landlords
Increased Brightline taxes
Increased Interest deductibility costs
Minimum wage rises above inflation
Taxes increasing greater than inflation

Back at you for those inflation busters delivered!
 
If something cost 6 in 2020 and it cost 8 in 2021 that's an increase of 33%. In one year. Now many variables can happen, including a wage rise. Excluding that and keeping it simple, the inflation is reduced in the next year and the same object goes up from 8 to 9 that following year. An increase of 12.5% relative to 8, and an increase of 15.66% relative to 6.

The price still went up, but by less than the previous year.

So it's come down but is also increasing, relative.

View attachment 4963
Oh please stop! I can see now why they thought there was no cost of living crisis.
 
Back
Top Bottom