Post Match Manly v Warriors - [Round 27, 2025]

[Tookey 2.0]

That was my thought, EIT has that freakish motor trait that is hard to come by plus appears to have the rest to go with it. Once he fills out fully could be a gun middle.

I'll put my hand up and say I really wasn't too sure about EIT in FG, but these last few games he's looked fantastic and someone I can see having a very long career with us. It could deffo be Leka and Laban with EIT on the bench and to cover centre for the next 10+ years. Really, really exciting prospects

 

[CWC]

Where the backs tho.
Salalilo and Sikuvaea will be the next middles up.
Out of that list I think Eddie shifts into the middle and Fatialofa to the centres

Eddie will be a breakout like Leka/Demi this year OMG, our pack’s gonna be awesome unless he keeps picking Marata

 

[sup42]

I was mentally disturbed watching that game
We were worse than last week
Lot of comments on Boyd
But can someone can pull up the statistics on how our forwards played
Erin Clark and Healy were good
What are the statistics for all our other forwards
The halves can only look bad if our forwards don’t perform

Truth is that every time we lose an experienced player the walls of the bus get thinner and the cracks widen.

Really missed Jackson Ford and Egan tonight.

The work load those boys get through quietly carries this game plan of ours for a good hour or so between them.

You cannot keep losing these grinders and expect us to look stable.

 

[Beastmode]

Webby has turned us into one hell of a boring team to watch …

Great when we were winning but now… what a snooze fest to watch

 

[JustLikeStartingOver]

They’ll bloody give anything a try these days. Unless it’s last week of course. Berry needs to take up study or learn a trade, how do you write yourself off if that situation

 

[FormerlyJamesW]

Hey, look on the bright side. We now have the record for the fastest try ever scored....

 

[sup42]

Webby has turned us into one hell of a boring team to watch …

Great when we were winning but now… what a snooze fest to watch

How can anyone keep watching this lot (especially after tonight) and not see that fundamentally the players are not good enough and no coach can correct that.

Capewell makes a break down the left flank, he is slow as, but doing his best, there is no one with him, this is not a one off scenario, this is a really good illustration of the truth that every back on that left edge is not good enough at one fundamental of football codes....support.

CNK was not there. He gets a small reprieve because a fullback cannot be everywhere all of the time, despite what people think.

None of our halves support, they do not get a pass, because Metcalf does it every time. The answer is CHT and Boyd are not good enough.

Our Left Winger who everyone praises for returns is a failure as an attacking player for not running after his slow Second rower.

Our Center is not there, that is another fail at NRL level.

Every back on that side of the field is not good enough.

Now go to the right edge and the issues are the same.

I did not want to get into putting our players down - but if it comes to this bullshit idea that somehow Andrew Webster is supposed to make good players out of our rubbish line up then I am gonna scream.

Webster did a brilliant job with Crap. And if people think throwing Sio Kali and Fatialofa in there they are kidding themselves, those blokes don't know how to tackle to an NRL standard yet.

 

[peteNZ]

What a lacklustre performance, same old mistakes, same old being caught out of position in kicks and plays. Penrith will kill is next week unless we sfart showing a few more brains. Going to be a short GF series for the Warriors.

.

 

[kurgal]

Important to keep perspective though. At the end of the day, we lost by one point....just one point!

 

[Adamnz support]

The NRL is a joke. 2 dodgy tries from the sea eagles. One was a double movement. You know it’s bad when the 1 eyed commentator are calling it out.


We were poor too. CNK can’t defend anything. DWZ needs to go. Tanah Boyd is not up to the job. CHT worse game in a jersey.

 

[Inruin]

Important to keep perspective though. At the end of the day, we lost by one point....just one point!

It may have been one point on the scoreboard....

 

[Stalefish540]

How can anyone keep watching this lot (especially after tonight) and not see that fundamentally the players are not good enough and no coach can correct that.

Capewell makes a break down the left flank, he is slow as, but doing his best, there is no one with him, this is not a one off scenario, this is a really good illustration of the truth that every back on that left edge is not good enough at one fundamental of football codes....support.

CNK was not there. He gets a small reprieve because a fullback cannot be everywhere all of the time, despite what people think.

None of our halves support, they do not get a pass, because Metcalf does it every time. The answer is CHT and Boyd are not good enough.

Our Left Winger who everyone praises for returns is a failure as an attacking player for not running after his slow Second rower.

Our Center is not there, that is another fail at NRL level.

Every back on that side of the field is not good enough.

Now go to the right edge and the issues are the same.

I did not want to get into putting our players down - but if it comes to this bullshit idea that somehow Andrew Webster is supposed to make good players out of our rubbish line up then I am gonna scream.

Webster did a brilliant job with Crap. And if people think throwing Sio Kali and Fatialofa in there they are kidding themselves, those blokes don't know how to tackle to an NRL standard yet.

So what are Cappy and Webby doing to change the backline?

No signings since taking over(that I can think of) and no signings next year to make any improvements...

 

[sup42]

So what are Cappy and Webby doing to change the backline?

No signings since taking over(that I can think of) and no signings next year to make any improvements...

Well they wanted Ali there as a genuine not slow attacking outside back. But a combo of injury and not pulling finger has hamstrung the planning dept.

Jae Linane, pace, vision, genuine attacking threat. When Metcalf is fit they will have pace both sides of the ruck.

Mellars, airial game.

Not a back but Gannon gives them a wide ranging back rower with a pass and pace for his size.

Looking at those two backline signings you can extrapolate the same old issue. People do not want to sign here from Aus.

Also gambling of ex Aus slack arse fast backs like you read on here is a complete waste of money and likely to end with us being screwed over by half arsed players.

It is not a simple fix.

 

[CWC]

Well I did say it’s Webby’s fault for not gradually building Berry’s fitness back into FG, he lasted 2 games this time before dislocating himself again by falling on the ground 1st set of D, we are watching a head on collision in slow motion

There was Egan limping with a dud hip and Leka’s still error prone from fatigue now

Who knows maybe the whole left edge were fatigued that they mentally switch off or didnt have the strength or will to chase Cape, CHT only missed 1 game with a calf (is that calf ok? He’s playing crap lately) Pompey is slow and Roger don’t know where he was

I saw some pundits blaming all black players for their poor form all year while I was thinking Razor deserve the pressure he’s under….bucks stop with him lol, players didnt pick themselves. What did Webby do when forwards take 2 runs a game? Play them some more!

 

[Boats n Hoes]

Thought the period of play straight after halftime summed up where we've been going wrong the last 6 weeks or so really.

We play out our 6 from the kick off, kick deep in their territory on the last. Start our grinding defence but give up that early penalty with the Sam Healy tackle.....they get an easy out of their end......then we compound that with some diabolical defence where Dimitri and Clark fall for Hunts dummy, and he waltzes round Charnze like he's wearing concrete boots (2nd week in a row he's been burned like that)

We just havent been able to amount or sustain pressure on the opposition.

For a team with limited strike who clearly relies on playing territory and ginding teams into errors giving us oppertunities......none of that is worth shit if we cant sustain pressure by giving away penalties or making errors which just kill any momentum for us before its started.....and this has been the story for us since probably that first Titans game really.

And if we arent hitting those KPI's we dont have the ability to play "footy" that other teams possess to get ourselves out of trouble.

Some are calling for mass changes to play an attack based game but tbh i just dont see it in the roster we have. Sure a couple of changes might make small incremental improvements in this regard but as much as fans want us to be able strike like a Bronco's or Dolphins or Roosters it aint gonna happen unless we recruit it, or we have some hidden gems in our development (particulary backs) who come out of nowhere......and im not seeing either of that in the works.

As much as its looks likely we've gone as far as we can Webby's playing/has played probably the only cards he could....while many want us to throw caution to the wind and throw the ball out of our arses for this last game......our best hope is probably doubling down and playing the most perfect "boring" "grinding" game we can.

 

[Dannevegas]

So what are Cappy and Webby doing to change the backline?

No signings since taking over(that I can think of) and no signings next year to make any improvements...

Mellars, Kali, Fatialofa, Norris, Hanson, Lynnane

 

[Riptide]

The NRL is a joke. 2 dodgy tries from the sea eagles. One was a double movement. You know it’s bad when the 1 eyed commentator are calling it out.


We were poor too. CNK can’t defend anything. DWZ needs to go. Tanah Boyd is not up to the job. CHT worse game in a jersey.

Throw in JFH as well!

 

[WHB]

Did Healy actually ground his try i didn't see it touch grass but hey ref gave it.

Simpkins was the same.
Guess they had to level it up.

 

[WHB]

Watched the game again and apart from the super fast Fish try at the start.

Manly came out with intentions.

There early exchanges were fierce.
It was the first game I seen Clark get stopped in his tracks at the collision.

Manly like playing us for some reason.
Sure for them they must see us as that team they can win most times.

Things came right once they absorbed the pressure.

 

[Fangrl1234]

Oh the horror! Just when u thought it couldn’t get worse, Webby brings in Harper to Partner Pompey in the centres. Explosiveness personified.

Well tell me who you you would have. Harper defensively is superior to others. Attack wise he has also stepped up and proved he is a possibility. Don’t know if you have been watching his games but I can’t see who you would be putting ahead of him. FYI - I have watched every nrl and naw cup game

I thought about Harper. But went with Fatialofa. But it will probably be Harper

Or Taine to FB and CNK to centre. That’s prob more like it