I've played a fair bit and I wouldn't be happy if I was the batsman. Turns out it wouldn't really have made much of a difference to the result the way our openers went.I think it's one where if you have played cricket a lot, you know it's out. As far as I'm concerned if fingers are under the ball it's out and we shouldn't over-analyse these things. It's only recently that the interpretation seems to be getting read a bit differently. Legitimate low catches always look suss on camera.
South Africans have been going off about it online though.
@Wrighty what did you think of it with all your years of experience?