I’d be ropeable if we let him go early
I'd be fucked off to the power of 3. As a fan it ma
Here is some tin foil hat theories for you.
I questioned at the time putting Linnane in the top 30. With Linnane we have 5 halves in our top 30 and there is a genuine opportunity cost to the balance of the squad by having too many of any position.
By putting Linane in the top 30 and MAYBE if you believe 5 and Last we offered Inch a top 30 role - have they known this has been coming for a while or at least had fears of it happening and built in some back up plans.
Very plausible theory and it is what I was thinking too. I still say that the delay is normal because he'll be wanting the highest price due to age, point of his career, was leading Dally M before he got injured. He'll want a 4-5 year million per season deal.
BUT, as you said we're now heavy in the halves. If Metcalfe left it would answer a few questions. It would explain why we have
Jye Linnane, Shane Hanson,
CHT, Boyd, Cleary, Thompson. You have an injury-prone star (Linnane),
CHT an experienced back-up, with Hanson our 'waiting to see if he has what we want', at 6. At 7 you'd have Boyd, Cleary, Thompson.
Which would mean you're looking at the year starting with
CHT/Boyd. This would piss off a lot of day 1 fans like myself because it always feels like the moment things are going good, something happens and we're re-building again. Never quite getting to the top. Always re-building.
It might explain thought why Inch's signing has not been confirmed. It may be conditional on whether Metcalfe resigns or not.
You then have
CHT/Boyd as placeholders for 2026. Linnane/Hanson fighting to supersede
CHT with Inch as the next developing 6. Over the next 2 years Linnane will either be injury-prone and we let him go or he cements 6 for the next 2/3 years. If he gets injured, Hanson will step up and be our 6 until Inch has learned the game enough to command a FG position.
Then Cleary would be pushing Boyd and may win out by year end. But then you're also asking
TMM/Hanson to cover 7. We'd be 6 heavy and 7 light. Not the best scenario but may benefit Cleary.
Either way, Metcalfe leaving would not be good short-term. Medium term we will be ok. But short term we'd be screwed next year.
CNK/
CHT/Boyd are not going to win us a premiership, we know this. Even
CNK/Linnane/Boyd won't be enough.
CNK or
Tuaupiki/Linnane/Metcalfe at least has a chance.