Pick Your Team Warriors v Dolphins - Round 12, 2024 PICK YOUR TEAM

[BangBro's (still banging)]

I hope webby is starting roache over lussick next week.

 

[FormerlyJamesW]

I hope webby is starting roache over lussick every week, now on.

Fixed

 

[The Warrior Waka]

Pikura, Riki, Carrigan. Best in the comp.

I rate Olakau'atu as good as if not better than those 3.

 

[MrFrankWhite]

TMM to retire at 28?

Whose development is TMM slowing down?

Hes already retired once. Or transition to hooker.

CHT, Metcalf, Hanson, Farr, Cleary all have to be more of the future than TMM.

 

[MrFrankWhite]

I rate Olakau'atu as good as if not better than those 3.

I wanst aware he plays all three positions. Does he collect 3 paychecks? What does his jersey like?;is it
11
12
13

or 111213

 

[The Warrior Waka]

I wanst aware he plays all three positions. Does he collect 3 paychecks? What does his jersey like?;is it
11
12
13

or 111213

Yes he does. Manly don't need the extra 2 people. Its just him. He's that good.
The number on his back is 121113. You were close.

 

[Inruin]

Hes already retired once. Or transition to hooker.

CHT, Metcalf, Hanson, Farr, Cleary all have to be more of the future than TMM.

CHT been off for a year and busted after a couple of games. Metcalf broken leg and will take time to get back to anywhere near what he was doing, Hanson shows promise but at least a couple of seasons away from first grade IMO. Farr . Cleary completely unproven whether he is even good enough yet and young. So yeah retire the only other experienced half we have going.

 

[The Warrior Waka]

I wanst aware he plays all three positions. Does he collect 3 paychecks? What does his jersey like?;is it
11
12
13

or 111213

 

[MrFrankWhite]

CHT been off for a year and busted after a couple of games. Metcalf broken leg and will take time to get back to anywhere near what he was doing, Hanson shows promise but at least a couple of seasons away from first grade IMO. Farr . Cleary completely unproven whether he is even good enough yet and young. So yeah retire the only other experienced half we have going.

I dont mean now lol.

But what TMM is our 6 next year? Cool then what? Again at 2026 at age 30? Bet hes heaps faster by then...

 

[Inruin]

I dont mean now lol.

But what TMM is our 6 next year? Cool then what? Again at 2026 at age 30? Bet hes heaps faster by then...

So retire at the end of the year? All my points still stand

 

[MrFrankWhite]

So retire at the end of the year? All my points still stand

They do. But so do mine. He's barely average now at 28, hes not getting any faster or better with age. Any young half with comparable skillset would be an upgrade.

 

[John Nick]

Today was a great example of what speed can do. Taine and Metcalf on the field together would be lethal imo

 

[Cces]

But what TMM is our 6 next year? Cool then what? Again at 2026 at age 30? Bet hes heaps faster by then...

He's never been selected ahead of Metcalf so if Metcalf's fit we're unlikely to see TMM at #6. Good peace of mind to have on the roster though.
Unsigned for 2026 so no need to get ahead of ourselves

 

[MrFrankWhite]

He's never been selected ahead of Metcalf so if Metcalf's fit were unlikely to see TMM at #6. Unsigned for 2026 so no need to get ahead of ourselves

I would really like to see him transition to hooker. We really need the help there and Egans body cant be relied upon. I actually like TMM

 

[Inruin]

They do. But so do mine. He's barely average now at 28, hes not getting any faster or better with age. Any young half with comparable skillset would be an upgrade.

Which we don't have. And SJ isn't going to get any less likely to be uninjured also. TMM first season back from a broken leg . Metcalf will take more time than people think to get back to where he was. The rest are I've covered.

IMHO if CHT can get a string of games injury free I'd probably go with him. If SJ plays on whoever is at 6 isn't going to get much opportunity to show what they can do unless SJ adjusts his play. And then you need injury cover for him.

 

[wizard of Tauranga]

I would really like to see him transition to hooker. We really need the help there and Egans body cant be relied upon. I actually like TMM

TMM is more scary around knocks to the head than Egan.

Way to much contact for TMM.

 

[MrFrankWhite]

We have JD Auloa coming through

I'll keep an eye out.

 

[Warrior#214]

I just want CNK RTS and TnT on the field at some stage. Make it happen Webby

 

[CWC]

It was amusing TT was shorter than Lara at the interview, played taller than Steven Adams though, must keep him in the line up and the squad going forward, heck could he be an option long term at halves which is a position that can go into mid 30s these days, so 25 is still young. Home grown player no issues with compassionate release and seems to stay fit most of the time unlike our other young halves

 

[run_it_str8_again]

I do not care who is named this week. I care that they apply themselves with the same intent, intensity, commitment and determination. That is what has been missing. And I loved seeing it in today's setting.

How the flying fox did we beat Penrith with this team? And lose the last bunch with our experienced incumbents and leaders. Today showed that SJ is not our saviour nor does he need to be. A team won today. The whole team.