CWC
🔍
General Is the Metcalf experience to halves over?
- Thread starter Playdaball
- Start date
- Status
Hope this is not a sequel
Milking!
📈
long answer short: the experience is not over.
I don’t get posts putting him at five-eight over CHT, then putting in Boyd or TMM at halfback - like how are they better than CHT? Or Metcalfe at halfback? TMM is a better ball player, but his long kicking game is dusty AF. Boys couldn’t crack it at the Titans. Would either of them have stopped Canberra’s forwards going nuts? Or the Storm being the Storm?
I don’t get posts putting him at five-eight over CHT, then putting in Boyd or TMM at halfback - like how are they better than CHT? Or Metcalfe at halfback? TMM is a better ball player, but his long kicking game is dusty AF. Boys couldn’t crack it at the Titans. Would either of them have stopped Canberra’s forwards going nuts? Or the Storm being the Storm?
Tohu’s_Knees
🛡️
We’re not going to win the premiership this year. IMO, 2027 is the year we’ll be pushing for it at the earliest. I’m talking about WINNING btw. Which means top 4.
There are 2 main roster holes in our squad.
The obvious.
6. CHT
7. Metcalf
First off, who else is there? (2027)
With the next 2 seasons under their belts they should be much more settled. If they can 35-40 out of 48 (minimum) games together over seasons 25-26. I think we’ll be better placed than most other clubs. Also if TMM is our cover half that’s great. (Highly unlikely)
The next hole is. (2027)
11. Capewell
12. Niukore
13. Clark
None of these 3 starts for a top 4 team.
NO I DON’T HATE CLARK. It just the truth.
The good news is by 2027 Capewell and Niukore will be moved on (Capewell definitely, I’d lowball Niukore with a minimum).
Halasima, Laban and Vaimauga will have 3 seasons under their belts.
I think Clark will be an excellent 14, similar to Walker. Different skill set, but a crucial FRESH injection at the 20 minute mark.
Also, we’ll have a settled (hopefully) centre pairing in Ali and Berry with hopefully some dynamic wingers.
An ageing front row might be a little worrying though.
There are 2 main roster holes in our squad.
The obvious.
6. CHT
7. Metcalf
First off, who else is there? (2027)
With the next 2 seasons under their belts they should be much more settled. If they can 35-40 out of 48 (minimum) games together over seasons 25-26. I think we’ll be better placed than most other clubs. Also if TMM is our cover half that’s great. (Highly unlikely)
The next hole is. (2027)
11. Capewell
12. Niukore
13. Clark
None of these 3 starts for a top 4 team.
NO I DON’T HATE CLARK. It just the truth.
The good news is by 2027 Capewell and Niukore will be moved on (Capewell definitely, I’d lowball Niukore with a minimum).
Halasima, Laban and Vaimauga will have 3 seasons under their belts.
I think Clark will be an excellent 14, similar to Walker. Different skill set, but a crucial FRESH injection at the 20 minute mark.
Also, we’ll have a settled (hopefully) centre pairing in Ali and Berry with hopefully some dynamic wingers.
An ageing front row might be a little worrying though.
I think we should utilise Boyd's kicking and organising skills. He seems to go okay in Cup
Two weeks in fact - is the bye not good for us? We need to keep our feet on the ground.
Sea Eagles despondent about how DCE's defection has had bad affect on team's performance. May be a fourth spot available.
I wish I was tech savvy enough to put together a Boyd 2024 Titans package.
Long story less long, it was grim to say the least. 2 from 10 with him as halfback from memory and one of those was our complete no show hiding against them.
If you've played enough NRL, driving a team round as a halfback at cup level is a cake walk comparatively because of the space and time you are given in that grade.
True. After all we got a flogging but at the hands of the Best team in the comp at this time of the year. We lost our glue JFH early and I think Storm would have demolished nearly every team on the day
They played the best side and current champions to be fair. Tanah may not have made a difference.
Gus did an interesting article recently and I can't find it but it was about the standard of Cup footy and how bad it is and getting worse.
Like going from Fox to NRL the difference is huge
Tohu’s_Knees
🛡️
Yeah, you might. So what? lol
The narrative around this guy has changed so much over the last couple months.
Originally, he got the role cause he’s a “ball player”. Hasn’t really been much of that.
Then…… it’s cause of his dynamic running game and quick play the ball. Which I actually agree with. It’s been exceptional.
Then……. It’s cause he “sets the tone in defence”. 18-0 when he came off.
(How people can tell that from the TV is a little funny to me, but ok)
Cause I went to a couple live games and it seemed like JFH and Barnett were the drivers IMO. But whatever.
Craig Bellamy has NEVER picked a player like Clark as his 13 (consistently). And his system has lasted 20 years……
Why didn’t he pick Brandon Smith at 13?Melbourne Storm B Smith is twice the player Clark is. (I’m not interested in his Roosters form with the benefit of hindsight)
Seibold absolutely wouldn’t.
And Maguire is leaning heavily into the “ball playing lock”. (Which Erin doesn’t really do much of, even though apparently that’s the original reason he got the job) They don’t need the yards that Clark gets with Haas and Carrigan.
Ok, maybe Salmon. Who isn’t playing badly btw. That’s a maybe.
run_it_str8_again
Guest
Barney eluded to the young blokes coming on and showing them how to defend. That's a poor sign on our seniors/incumbents/leaders which includes our two koro second rowers
run_it_str8_again
Guest
The concern so far given that we are in the 8 and not struggling as much as some others at this very moment is that we are so very inconsistent. This is my opinion backed my no research.
Granted but suggest his experience must be useful and his goal kicking is more reliable compared with Luke (particularly from not in front)
roguei
🔥
Nah that is more than fair. If we just gave Ivan that 2+ year extension he wanted to coach we'd of only had the one.
If Luke Metcalf went to Melbourne do you think Bellamy could turn him into a genuine 7?
- Status
