Politics 🗳️ NZ Politics

Populist policy to give money away (trying to buy votes) in an election year.

The oil shock is a supply problem. The price needs to go up to change people’s behaviour, lower demand and avert an even bigger crisis.

Cash makes people happy but makes the crisis WORSE because people will buy more fuel, forcing prices even higher.

Election year… they should have subsidised public transport.
They should have included the elderly. The old Bentley takes a fair whack of 98 at $3.50 a litre. May have to go to an Aston, think they make a Diesel model

Oh, and public transport is a myth in this country
 
They should have included the elderly. The old Bentley takes a fair whack of 98 at $3.50 a litre. May have to go to an Aston, think they make a Diesel model

Oh, and public transport is a myth in this country
Yes Rick and in my situation I am in my late 70's and work from home so it's not a petrol thing for me but I'm getting absolutely nothing.
 
Like most populists JN, they would look at the polls, focus groups etc etc and then decide what they think will get them the most likes. (Votes)

What they forget is that no one likes them anyway
On a serious note I have been told that NZ Healthcare workers are being more selective of their jobs as they do get a travel allowance but it needs to increase given the current situation. That's fair enough imo
Might just be something that Willis has overlooked but unfortunately some people who rely on this service for food health care and cleanliness issues will be stuck at home with no assistance
 
Last edited:
I hear Willis saying she can't adjust the benefits because the law states how much they should get and it's fixed in the Budget. Somehow, I don't think the parties on the left would have opposed a "one off" change to the benefit legislation for this year to allow extra for the current petrol pricing.

Personally, while I wouldn't want to see it being a "universal" payment/petrol tax reduction, I do think it should have had a broader target.
 
I hear Willis saying she can't adjust the benefits because the law states how much they should get and it's fixed in the Budget. Somehow, I don't think the parties on the left would have opposed a "one off" change to the benefit legislation for this year to allow extra for the current petrol pricing.

Personally, while I wouldn't want to see it being a "universal" payment/petrol tax reduction, I do think it should have had a broader target.
She has labeled it
Timely Temporary and Targeted
More like
Timid Thoughtless and Tactless
 
In the 30's during the great depression probably. Roosevelt essentially laid the platform for a Governments role in assisting during tough financial times.
Agree the govt should assist in a counter cyclical manner - eg pump money into the economy during bad times and ease off during good times.

Problem is threading off but doesn’t happen. Costs are locked into future budget. Since Covid we’ve run at a loss, borrowed and have reduced capacity to handle the next economic shock.
 
Agree the govt should assist in a counter cyclical manner - eg pump money into the economy during bad times and ease off during good times.

Problem is threading off but doesn’t happen. Costs are locked into future budget. Since Covid we’ve run at a loss, borrowed and have reduced capacity to handle the next economic shock.
Agree with you there. Hard to tell the future though!
 
They should have included the elderly. The old Bentley takes a fair whack of 98 at $3.50 a litre. May have to go to an Aston, think they make a Diesel model

Oh, and public transport is a myth in this country
There is a couple of exceptions to the PT myth.
Auckland say between GlenInnes Onehunga Mt Albert City area is actually very well served.
I di three days in Auckland up till Monday and didnt use a car -20 bus and train trips for $49.50.
I was a bit miffed on missing Auckland Transports fifity dollar seven day fare cap.
 
There is a couple of exceptions to the PT myth.
Auckland say between GlenInnes Onehunga Mt Albert City area is actually very well served.
I di three days in Auckland up till Monday and didnt use a car -20 bus and train trips for $49.50.
I was a bit miffed on missing Auckland Transports fifity dollar seven day fare cap.
Should have clarified Kos. Was referring to PT between centres. While there are buses and aircraft available, the price and schedules can be unsuitable. One of the disadvantages of living in a country where the population is small and spread out.

City wise, it's ok, even down here the bus service is pretty good
 
  • Like
Reactions: kos
Should have clarified Kos. Was referring to PT between centres. While there are buses and aircraft available, the price and schedules can be unsuitable. One of the disadvantages of living in a country where the population is small and spread out.

City wise, it's ok, even down here the bus service is pretty good
West Auckland is a black hole in parts. 35 mins by car before 6am, public transport from where I am to where I work is 1 hr 45 one way
 
It peaked around the same price about a week ago (~$112).

In 2022 there was no media silence, in fact the public and media outcry over the fuel prices was so intense the Labour government announced the emergency 25c/l cut to the fuel excise tax. Arguably they were more focused on it than it is now..

Please stop posting unfounded rubbish from randoms on Twitter/X
 
Back
Top Bottom