Politics 🗳️ NZ Politics

🤖 AI Summary

📝 Summary:

The thread centers on New Zealand's upcoming election, primarily debating the economic management and policy differences between the center-left Labour government and center-right National/ACT opposition. Key criticisms target Labour's fiscal stewardship, citing ballooning government expenditure #7#272, housing unaffordability, and unfulfilled promises like KiwiBuild and dental care expansion #16#12. A user #7 highlighted Labour's annual 9% spending growth versus 1.5% under previous governments, arguing this fueled inflation. National's tax-cut policy faced scrutiny over funding gaps and legality, with user #215 questioning Luxon's reliance on "trust me" assurances.
Leadership competence emerged as a critical theme, particularly in later posts. Luxon drew heavy criticism after a contentious interview where he struggled to defend policy details #194#199#211, while Willis faced backlash for her economic credentials. Hipkins garnered fleeting praise for articulation but was ultimately seen as representing poor governmental outcomes #45#119. A trusted user #308 presented expert economic analysis contradicting Treasury optimism. Infrastructure issues—like Wellington's water crisis and the dental school staffing shortage—were cited as examples of systemic mismanagement #235#12. Notable policy debates included road-user charges for EVs #220, immigration impacts on rents #299, and coalition scenarios involving NZ First #182#258. Early fringe discussions on candidates' rugby allegiances gave way to substantive policy critiques, culminating in grim Treasury forecasts discussed in posts #271#304#308. User #168 also revealed concerns about Labour rushing regulatory changes to entrench policies pre-election.

🏷️ Tags:

Economic Policies, Housing Crisis, Leadership Competence

📊 Data Source: Based on ALL posts in thread (total: 10000 posts) | ⏱️ Total Generation Time: 20s
You don't have permission to regenerate AI summary.

NZWarriors.com

And I guarantee Norway's health system is in far better shape than ours, which is being privatised at a rate of knots in this far right government.

And if it's an equitable system a large portion of the population would go when they actually got sick initially, or even be able to implement preventative measures, instead of the not-even-an-ambulance-at-the-bottom system we have now, where people are dying because the system is under huge strain, deliberately being run down by this far right neoliberal government.

Oh and the government could very well set power prices if it were not constrained by a neoliberal straitjacket. Or at the very least provide an alternative that could be much cheaper to all new zealanders.

Coincidentally the butter prices seem to be exorbitantly high at the same time as a proposed multi billion dollar sale to a French consortium. Selling off the family jewels at the expense of all New Zealanders.

Do tell. Quelle surprise.

You seem to have taken a right turn lately Mike.
The problem with a lot of the commentary these days about tax cuts is that the money, if the government hadn't changed the thresholds, could only be used once. So, $3 billion to buy ferries this year means it's gone... it can't also be used on the health system or social welfare, or social housing in the same year as it's gone.

So, when someone says that we should use it to fully fund a public health system like Norway, it wouldn't do it as the additional cost to NZ is $24 billion PA.... one hell of a out more the $3 billion tax cuts PA.

It has nothing to do with being left, right or cental.... just about having an honest look at the figures.

BTW, Fonterra selling off part of it's business to the French has no effect on the price of butter... during the Global Dairy Trade Auction where the price is set. As with all auctions, the buyers set the value... not the sellers... especially not in the case of the GDT Auctions as there is no reserve set by the seller. What the buyers are willing to pay is what the seller gets.
 
Who would’ve thought the global cost of living crisis was caused by nz raising the minimum wage.
You learn a lot from this forum.

Or perhaps this illustrate why its better to travel to countries to see how they live rather than vegetate on cruises.
Not caused by, but certainly contributed to. Raise the minimum wage and there’s a cascading impact across all other wage brackets. Local businesses have to lift prices to offset, or alternatively cut staff numbers. It directly feeds into non-tradeable inflation.
 
Meanwhile, the silence on this hard right extreme government is damning
View attachment 14222

Funny how a lot of what's happening with the state of the economy at the moment can go back to NZ's COVID response when the economy was over stimulated by both the RBNZ and the then government. Then, the RB was too slow to more the OCR and too slow to drop it... all while, for the first nine months of the COVID response, NZ First was supporting the government. Mr Jones, part of the reason we haven't recovered, compared to most countries, come back to your parties actions.

Amazing the short memories Winnie and Jones have.... when it suits them!!!
 
Turns out ignoring climate change is damaging in more ways than one

The author of the MFE got a couple of things seriously wrong. The US won't be worried about whether or not NZ meets its Paris obligations as the US never signed up to it.

Also, the Climate Action Tracker from Brilliant Maps shows no countries met the Paris Agreement requirements.... pretty hard for any other country to criticise NZ for not meeting a standard they also failed to meet....

1755836274789.webp

 
Not caused by, but certainly contributed to. Raise the minimum wage and there’s a cascading impact across all other wage brackets. Local businesses have to lift prices to offset, or alternatively cut staff numbers. It directly feeds into non-tradeable inflation.
I've just been on a trip around the world and one of my takeaways was how similar the issues all the countries are were grappling with are to ours here.

Your tourist mogul mate from TGA was saying it was the only cause and then comparing it to the NZ minimum wage without the context of the exchange rate or their tipping culture or even the US isn't an economy we should aspire to be like at all.

To blame the cost of living on minimum wage while being unable to acknowledge it's an issue happening nearly everywhere is rather dumb.
 
Is the person banned from seeing or commenting on my posts talking about me?

For context I’ve been to 30+ countries, am a frequent traveller and the cruise was my 4th overseas holiday this year (not work, holiday!) 🤷‍♂️
 
Not caused by, but certainly contributed to. Raise the minimum wage and there’s a cascading impact across all other wage brackets. Local businesses have to lift prices to offset, or alternatively cut staff numbers. It directly feeds into non-tradeable inflation.
What do you imagine would have happened if the min wage was still fixed $15.75, would it have been deflationary? Would it have crashed the housing market, or would property values and rents have stayed at 2017 levels?
 
Back
Top Bottom