Post Match Manly v Warriors - [Round 27, 2025]

[kos]

I was mentally disturbed watching that game
We were worse than last week
Lot of comments on Boyd
But can someone can pull up the statistics on how our forwards played
Erin Clark and Healy were good
What are the statistics for all our other forwards
The halves can only look bad if our forwards don’t perform

 

[Fangrl1234]

The fact he didn't play centre today after the injury makes the suggestion doubtful.

Looking at stats and defensive reads - Harper should be next man up. Unless webby wants to put someone who is available next year in

 

[snake77]

Again too many mistakes. A lot of passes that shouldn't have been thrown that put the catcher under too much pressure. Or gave them no chance to catch it with them being too close and it thrown like a rocket at their chest.

This time of the year if you are heading for finals football you need to be able to defend your tryline. We seem to start with the yips and eventually get better.

Manly also made a lot of mistakes so we had plenty of opportunities.

 

[Wellington Taniwha]

What did everyone think of the call when CNK was taken out trying to defend the bomb. It was mute since the Manly player got held up.

But surely that was the perfect time to call the attackers as disruptors? They didn't have their hands in a position to catch the ball and pretty much denied the defender a chance to compete for the ball.

Or that try which the manly player went up for the ball took his eyes off it and knocked on. Ref called it a knock on but the bunker overturned it

 

[The Warrior Waka]

Looking at stats and defensive reads - Harper should be next man up. Unless webby wants to put someone who is available next year in

I thought about Harper. But went with Fatialofa. But it will probably be Harper

 

[John Nick]

The really funny thing is, Dallin made some piss poor decisions, but those ones were the ones we got lucky and Tom duffed it up. Twice he came in when Leka had the center/FB covered but they made errors.

The two tries (well at least one I remember) where he was out flanked I'm sure his insides fucked him over. Yes, Dallin gets caught in no man's land but it's the poor decisions inside him that leads to that. I do wish he'd fucking nail someone though, because most of the time he's left clutching air

Yes. The first one was more on Berry but the others Dallin has to own

 

[Wrighty]

That was imo the worst performance all year. Dallin made some terrible defensive decisions, I’ve actually backed him so far this year due to the clear defensive systems but tonight was bad. Marata ran for 58m, in 55m. Hes deadwood, and needs to fuck off.

Probably tanners worst game in his career. Obviously still back him, but he was out on his feet after 15mins, leaking line breaks and missing tackles. Not quite up to it, yet.

Tanah showed his limitations tonight, but I feel like CHT needs to step up & give him a bloody hand. When things aren’t going well, take the bull by the hands & take the line on.

Erin Clark for player of the year for me, without him our middle gets absolutely rolled.

It’s extremely frustrating. We know what to do, Webby knows what to do, they’re just not doing it. Giving piggy back penalties, stupid errors (9 in the first half wtf!), and continually poor decisions on the edge. It’s really not that hard, but we’re just not all on the same page & the team is extremely low on confidence. They essentially need to forget tonight happened & start again next week.

I am wondering if TSS is a myth after what i saw tonight. Needs to go back to cup to work on some things. Where that leaves us for next week I don't know. I looked at NRL injury list tonight and it says Laban back in the finals. If we get real lucky he is back next week? surely not?

 

[CWC]

That was imo the worst performance all year. Dallin made some terrible defensive decisions, I’ve actually backed him so far this year due to the clear defensive systems but tonight was bad. Marata ran for 58m, in 55m. Hes deadwood, and needs to fuck off.

Probably tanners worst game in his career. Obviously still back him, but he was out on his feet after 15mins, leaking line breaks and missing tackles. Not quite up to it, yet.

Tanah showed his limitations tonight, but I feel like CHT needs to step up & give him a bloody hand. When things aren’t going well, take the bull by the hands & take the line on.

Erin Clark for player of the year for me, without him our middle gets absolutely rolled.

It’s extremely frustrating. We know what to do, Webby knows what to do, they’re just not doing it. Giving piggy back penalties, stupid errors (9 in the first half wtf!), and continually poor decisions on the edge. It’s really not that hard, but we’re just not all on the same page & the team is extremely low on confidence. They essentially need to forget tonight happened & start again next week.

The only way to prevent repeated dumb plays is to drop players for accountability earlier in the season. Especially when Barney is not there

 

[MrFrankWhite]

Pretty hard to without Nathan Cleary as he is Penrith. But ye I do agree that’s what he’s trying to do, which I don’t agree with. Just play footy with a steely edge on Defence

I nearly agree, but then Webbys record enters the conversation.... I have to back him

 

[Leon Black]

Thank god for The Paper, really need it after that performance. Manly were horrendous, imagine what the Panthers or Chooks will do to us next week. Thanks fuck for NSW Cup

 

[Zaggo]

I am wondering if TSS is a myth after what i saw tonight. Needs to go back to cup to work on some things. Where that leaves us for next week I don't know. I looked at NRL injury list tonight and it says Laban back in the finals. If we get real lucky he is back next week? surely not?

Ford will take most of TSSs minutes, thank god.

 

[CWC]

I am wondering if TSS is a myth after what i saw tonight. Needs to go back to cup to work on some things. Where that leaves us for next week I don't know. I looked at NRL injury list tonight and it says Laban back in the finals. If we get real lucky he is back next week? surely not?

Was hoping EIT would take on Laban’s role then he injured his shoulder, what a year

Laban probably ready for the GF

TSS looks like a good depth prop,, we are in trouble if he’s our future starting prop

 

[Fangrl1234]

I thought about Harper. But went with Fatialofa. But it will probably be Harper

It should be Harper but who knows. He has the experience and stats wise he is ahead of others. I guess it depends on whether we want to blood others. Apparently Harper is in Australia - not confirmed - just what I have heard

 

[Warriorsfan92]

I am wondering if TSS is a myth after what i saw tonight. Needs to go back to cup to work on some things. Where that leaves us for next week I don't know. I looked at NRL injury list tonight and it says Laban back in the finals. If we get real lucky he is back next week? surely not?

Ford will come in

 

[Leon Black]

Webster needs to take ownership of the back half of the season and stop being fun guy with the media, or he’ll end up in the studios before he knows it

 

[Wrighty]

What is happening with Leiataua ? Anyone?

 

[Wrighty]

Ford will come in

But EIT looks like he is out. So TSS stays but with less minutes?

 

[Dannevegas]

It should be Harper but who knows. He has the experience and stats wise he is ahead of others. I guess it depends on whether we want to blood others. Apparently Harper is in Australia - not confirmed - just what I have heard

Oh the horror! Just when u thought it couldn’t get worse, Webby brings in Harper to Partner Pompey in the centres. Explosiveness personified.

 

[CWC]

What is happening with Leiataua ? Anyone?

Got an ankle the equivalent of Berry’s shoulder

 

[tajhay]

Who is the most disappointing player of the season?

For mine its a tie between DWZ and JFH.

Dallin used to do the dumbest shit ie offloading on 1st tackle to noone but now hes stopped that he just dumb shit on defence. I like his runs and energy but his defence is so shot...today was just fumbling it whenever the ball wemt near him.

We cannot start with TSS next week.