Social Wrighty's Player Agent Game Rules posted

[Mr. Brownstone]

I feel 8 is to much personally. 6 is good. I just think legends should be filling key positions more that slotting in current players around legends.

Happy with whatever you think.

I think leave it to each player to decide who they select. If people want to run the Hodges gauntlet & stack their side with his players then let them.

 

[Wrighty]

I think leave it to each player to decide who they select. If people want to run the Hodges gauntlet & stack their side with his players then let them.

I am trying to decide mr B if we eliminate 5 more and make it a top 70. That would make it 0.5 legends less per contestant and shift the range from 4 to 8 to 3,5 to 7.5 However that feels like fiddling at the fringes a bit and may not make a material difference to Wizards concerns.
What do you think @Warriors55 or @Defence

Trim a few more legends down or is 75 a good number.

 

[Defence]

I am trying to decide mr B if we eliminate 5 more and make it a top 70. That would make it 0.5 legends less per contestant and shift the range from 4 to 8 to 3,5 to 7.5 However that feels like fiddling at the fringes a bit and may not make a material difference to Wizards concerns.
What do you think @Warriors55 or @Defence

Trim a few more legends down or is 75 a good number.

I’m thinking trim them but shit it’s hard deciding who to leave out.
Priddis over hodgson if that helps….

 

[Wrighty]

Thanks Defence - below is a suggestion for a further 5 eliminated.

1. Greg Bird
2. Jesse Bromwich
3. Todd Carney
4. Matt Cooper
5. Andrew Fifita
6. Israel Folau
7. Kurt Gidley
8. James Graham
9. Tohu Harris
10. Josh Hodgson
11. Karmichael Hunt
12. Shaun Johnson
13. Ali Lauiti’iti
14. Isaac Luke
15. Simon Mannering
16. Joey Manu
17. Willie Mason
18. Michael Morgan
19. Josh Morris
20. Mitchell Pearce
21. Luke Priddis
22. Frank Pritchard
23. Tony Puletua
24. Semi Radradra
25. Wendell Sailor
26. Glenn Stewart
27. Sam Thaiday
28. Clinton Toopi
29. Lote Tuqiri
30. Nigel Vagana
31. Manu Vatuvei
32. Jarred Warea-Hargreaves
33. Craig Wing
34. Tony Williams

Need to Eliminate 13 players - Suggest the following I have added 5.

1. Matt Cooper
2. James Graham
3. Josh Hodgson
4. Michael Morgan
5. Tohu Harris
6. Josh Morris
7. Mitchell Pearce
8. Tony Puletua
9. JWH
10. Sam Thaiday
11. Clinton Toopi
12. Karmichael Hunt
13. Semi Radradra

 

[Mr. Brownstone]

Thanks Defence - below is a suggestion for a further 5 eliminated.

1. Greg Bird
2. Jesse Bromwich
3. Todd Carney
4. Matt Cooper
5. Andrew Fifita
6. Israel Folau
7. Kurt Gidley
8. James Graham
9. Tohu Harris
10. Josh Hodgson
11. Karmichael Hunt
12. Shaun Johnson
13. Ali Lauiti’iti
14. Isaac Luke
15. Simon Mannering
16. Joey Manu
17. Willie Mason
18. Michael Morgan
19. Josh Morris
20. Mitchell Pearce
21. Luke Priddis
22. Frank Pritchard
23. Tony Puletua
24. Semi Radradra
25. Wendell Sailor
26. Glenn Stewart
27. Sam Thaiday
28. Clinton Toopi
29. Lote Tuqiri
30. Nigel Vagana
31. Manu Vatuvei
32. Jarred Warea-Hargreaves
33. Craig Wing
34. Tony Williams

Need to Eliminate 13 players - Suggest the following I have added 5.

1. Matt Cooper
2. James Graham
3. Josh Hodgson
4. Michael Morgan
5. Tohu Harris
6. Josh Morris
7. Josh Hodgson
8. Tony Puletua
9. JWH
10. Sam Thaiday
11. Mitchell Pearce
12. Karmichael Hunt
13. Semi Radradra

Def don’t agree agree with Hunt, JWH or Radradra. Hunt kept Slater from the Queensland fullback spot for quite some time, JWH is often selected at prop in team of the decades, and I genuinely think Radradra is one of the best wingers I’ve seen.

 

[Wrighty]

Def don’t agree agree with Hunt, JWH or Radradra. Hunt kept Slater from the Queensland fullback spot for quite some time, JWH is often selected at prop in team of the decades, and I genuinely think Radradra is one of the best wingers I’ve seen.

1) do you want to have an attempt to suggest some better alternatives to eliminate. I want to cross 5 more names off.
2) please note I had Hodgson written down twice so I have listed Toopi to eliminate on the list as well which you may disagree with but feel free to come up with 5 names?????

 

[Mr. Brownstone]

1) do you want to have an attempt to suggest some better alternatives to eliminate. I want to cross 5 more names off.
2) please note I had Hodgson written down twice so I have listed Toopi to eliminate on the list as well which you may disagree with but feel free to come up with 5 names?????

If prob axe Tate & El Masri from the original top 50 list

 

[Wrighty]

If prob axe Tate & El Masri from the original top 50 list

Hmm...I think we need to keep the top 50 list intact in case people have already been working on the list and planning around it.

 

[Wrighty]

We could kill off T-Rex though if things are getting squeaky tight.

 

[Mr. Brownstone]

Hmm...I think we need to keep the top 50 list intact in case people have already been working on the list and planning around it.

I doubt anyone’s strategically planning around Tate & El Masri. I’d also axe Preston Campbell

 

[Wrighty]

I doubt anyone’s strategically planning around Tate & El Masri. I’d also axe Preston Campbell

We will have to agree to disagree Preston Campbell is on my radar, And I am having trouble thinking of affordable centres so if I can swoop in on Tate at a budget price i am taking him.

How about I suggest a couple more elimination options and you can knock them back. Give me 5 minutes. We are nearly there if we knock T Rex out. Just need two more I think.

 

[Mr. Brownstone]

We will have to agree to disagree Preston Campbell is on my radar, And I am having trouble thinking of affordable centres so if I can swoop in on Tate at a budget price i am taking him.

How about I suggest a couple more elimination options and you can knock them back. Give me 5 minutes. We are nearly there if we knock T Rex out. Just need two more I think.

All good, & just my opinions.

 

[Wrighty]

Original 34 suggested players

1. Greg Bird
2. Jesse Bromwich
3. Todd Carney
4. Matt Cooper
5. Andrew Fifita
6. Israel Folau
7. Kurt Gidley
8. James Graham
9. Tohu Harris
10. Josh Hodgson
11. Karmichael Hunt
12. Shaun Johnson
13. Ali Lauiti’iti
14. Isaac Luke
15. Simon Mannering
16. Joey Manu
17. Willie Mason
18. Michael Morgan
19. Josh Morris
20. Mitchell Pearce
21. Luke Priddis
22. Frank Pritchard
23. Tony Puletua
24. Semi Radradra
25. Wendell Sailor
26. Glenn Stewart
27. Sam Thaiday
28. Clinton Toopi
29. Lote Tuqiri
30. Nigel Vagana
31. Manu Vatuvei
32. Jarred Warea-Hargreaves
33. Craig Wing
34. Tony Williams

Need to Eliminate 13 players have adjusted this since last post

1. Matt Cooper
2. James Graham
3. Josh Hodgson
4. Michael Morgan
5. Tohu Harris
6. Josh Morris
7. Mitchell Pearce
8. Tony Puletua
9. Frank Pritchard
10. Sam Thaiday
11. Clinton Toopi
12. Tony Williams
13. Ali Lauiti’iti or Manu Vatuvei or Nigel Vagana