Social Wrighty's Player Agent Game Rules posted

NZWarriors.com

Actually just Barrett, thought Bromwich was there but he isn’t.
I am not taking Bromwich under any circumstances. By the time I started watching in 2018 his peak was behind him and he had become a pay cheque player. I am in it to win it this year (Mr B be warned) but also have pet players and pet hates.
 
I am not taking Bromwich under any circumstances. By the time I started watching in 2018 his peak was behind him and he had become a pay cheque player. I am in it to win it this year (Mr B be warned) but also have pet players and pet hates.
That’s harsh on bromwhich- best prop of his generation imho.
I find in these games though, how a player ended their career has a big impact on the general consensus.
 
In all honesty I can myself getting too invested in which players should and shouldn't be included in the top 50 list so I am going to stay out of it and just deal with whatever the final list is.

One thing I will say though is that there needs to be a kind of even spread of players for different positions.

Not much good having 20 halves and 30 all other positions etc (not saying that will happen but will good to have an even spread for each position)
 
Actually just Barrett, thought Bromwich was there but he isn’t.
Any other comments on the list of additions - or I will nominate it to Tajhay. I realised today we have visited this topic before as we came up with a wildcard rule. However I think the new idea as better and avoids issues/more up front.
 
In all honesty I can myself getting too invested in which players should and shouldn't be included in the top 50 list so I am going to stay out of it and just deal with whatever the final list is.

One thing I will say though is that there needs to be a kind of even spread of players for different positions.

Not much good having 20 halves and 30 all other positions etc (not saying that will happen but will good to have an even spread for each position)
Here’s the list of those players with their primary NRL positions (noting where some played multiple roles):
PlayerPrimary Position(s)
Matt OrfordHalfback
Trent BarrettFive-eighth / Five-eighth–Lock utility
Todd CarneyFive-eighth / Halfback
Glenn StewartLock / Second-row
Wendell SailorWinger
Lote TuqiriWinger / Centre
Frank PritchardSecond-row / Lock
Manu VatuveiWinger
Steve MataiCentre
Simon ManneringLock / Second-row / Centre (early career)
Jared Waerea-Hargreaves (JWH)Prop
Jesse BromwichProp
Tohu HarrisSecond-row / Lock
Joseph (Joey) ManuCentre / Fullback
Ben CreaghSecond-row / Lock
Israel FolauCentre / Winger / Fullback
Karmichael HuntFullback / Five-eighth
Kurt GidleyFullback / Halfback / Five-eighth / Hooker (utility)
Jamal IdrisCentre / Second-row
Akuila UateWinger
Tony Williams (T-Rex)Second-row / Lock / occasionally Centre or Prop
Blake FergusonWinger / Centre
Semi RadradraWinger
Shaun JohnsonHalfback / Five-eighth
 
Here’s the list of those players with their primary NRL positions (noting where some played multiple roles):
PlayerPrimary Position(s)
Matt OrfordHalfback
Trent BarrettFive-eighth / Five-eighth–Lock utility
Todd CarneyFive-eighth / Halfback
Glenn StewartLock / Second-row
Wendell SailorWinger
Lote TuqiriWinger / Centre
Frank PritchardSecond-row / Lock
Manu VatuveiWinger
Steve MataiCentre
Simon ManneringLock / Second-row / Centre (early career)
Jared Waerea-Hargreaves (JWH)Prop
Jesse BromwichProp
Tohu HarrisSecond-row / Lock
Joseph (Joey) ManuCentre / Fullback
Ben CreaghSecond-row / Lock
Israel FolauCentre / Winger / Fullback
Karmichael HuntFullback / Five-eighth
Kurt GidleyFullback / Halfback / Five-eighth / Hooker (utility)
Jamal IdrisCentre / Second-row
Akuila UateWinger
Tony Williams (T-Rex)Second-row / Lock / occasionally Centre or Prop
Blake FergusonWinger / Centre
Semi RadradraWinger
Shaun JohnsonHalfback / Five-eighth
How many extra players do you want to add?
 
I’d prob select additional players from the following list (no doubt I’m forgetting obvious inclusions):

Greg Bird
Jesse Bromwich
Todd Carney
Matt Cooper
Andrew Fifita
Israel Folau
Kurt Gidley
James Graham
Tohu Harris
Josh Hodgson
Karmichael Hunt
Shaun Johnson
Ali Lauiti’iti
Isaac Luke
Simon Mannering
Joey Manu
Willie Mason
Michael Morgan
Josh Morris
Mitchell Pearce
Luke Priddis
Frank Pritchard
Tony Puletua
Semi Radradra
Wendell Sailor
Glenn Stewart
Sam Thaiday
Clinton Toopi
Lote Tuqiri
Nigel Vagana
Manu Vatuvei
Jarred Warea-Hargreaves
Craig Wing
 
How many extra players do you want to add?
The ideal goal was to add players who were better than Brent Tate and then evaluate if that is too many? I think we might to want to add some of those hookers you listed as well .

Maybe we could come at it from that angle first

But off the top of my head 20 including the extra hookers and maybe one or two above twenty so the cut off isn't arbitrary.

What do you think feels right ? or maybe if you or someone can go through the list of currently 24 extras and say which ones are better than Tate?
 
I’d prob select additional players from the following list (no doubt I’m forgetting obvious inclusions):

Greg Bird
Jesse Bromwich
Todd Carney
Matt Cooper
Andrew Fifita
Israel Folau
Kurt Gidley
James Graham
Tohu Harris
Josh Hodgson
Karmichael Hunt
Shaun Johnson
Ali Lauiti’iti
Isaac Luke
Simon Mannering
Joey Manu
Willie Mason
Michael Morgan
Josh Morris
Mitchell Pearce
Luke Priddis
Frank Pritchard
Tony Puletua
Semi Radradra
Wendell Sailor
Glenn Stewart
Sam Thaiday
Clinton Toopi
Lote Tuqiri
Nigel Vagana
Manu Vatuvei
Jarred Warea-Hargreaves
Craig Wing
Are all those better than Tate?
 

Similar threads

Back
Top Bottom