Squad is extremely meh on paper. We're absolutely a marquee player short, probably 2. Can't blame the recruitment, all their signings are sharp. Just no one wants to come here when they can stay in Aus, apart from when we're lucky. Webby's doing fantastic things with very average squads.
Real question is why are none of the kiwi backs (apart from the worst one by far CNK, no offense to him he's just cooked) play for us. A bunch of young stars playing for other teams. I'm sure the club is doing everything it can to mitigate it, but there is plenty of kiwi talent not playing for us.
I think I tend to disagree here. I think we have a couple of weak points within the squad/team but overall I rate it strongly.
Our young forwards have an extra year and preseason of NRL under their belts, Halasima, Vaimauga, Laban, EIT are a core of young forwards most teams would be jealous of.
A hooking rotation of Egan and Healey is solid potentially exciting depending on go forward and how much game time Healey gets.
Lock of the year.
JFH, Barnett starting props. Both offer different things but equally valuable.
Follow that with depth of Ford, Capewell, Niukore, TSS. Very reasonable replacements.
Our backs are where I think the unease is for me.
I hope we get a serviceable season from CNK, anything above that is a bonus.
RTS is a rock in the backline with effort and consistently high performance.
The other wing is a toss up, I’d prefer AKP to start, if we’re going to have a defensive liability I’d prefer one with legitimate blistering speed.
Centre is a massive question mark, not negatively, just really don’t know what to expect. I think Berry if healthy offers the most. But that’s incredibly hopeful.
Between Pompey and Leiataua for the other spot.
I have nothing against CHT I just don’t know where he fits and if 6 is his position.
Metcalf is the key. He is our premier HB and attacking threat. It was obvious to all how different we were once he went down.
Then the unknowns, to me, could be nothing, could be X-factors.
Gannon, Linnane, Fatialofa, Mellars. High hopes but no expectations.
TMM, Tuapiki and Boyd are players I don’t see fitting anywhere. Boyd will no doubt start the season at 7 until Metcalf is back but unless he’s paired with a creative 6 I don’t think he can be the attack we’re going to need.
The squad looks strong to me. Health will obviously play a key part as will development of new recruits and youngsters but meh is not what I would describe it as.