Highlighted posts

    If you happen to get bored again & update.
    Elia is still U17. Whether or not he remains a half is unknown though after being used in the Second Row for St Thomas' and at Lock for Canterbury.
    Hoani-Manuera Kahukiwa, from Christchurch, is already up in Auckland preparing for Matt's so I'd lock him in there amongst their Centre's
    Offseason boredom levels peaking
    Cheers for all the feedback - updated for Brandon Norris, Nganatatfu Vake, remove Compton Purcell, Move Christiano Elia, Remove Alapati Tusa Soagia. Happy to update as we get content on this pipeline through preseason!
    Screenshot 2025-11-07 at 9.21.49 AM.webp
     
    Hes in a stable condition now and awake and out of ICU

    The uncle of Eliesa Katoa has confirmed the Tongan star is in a stable condition and has been moved out of intensive care as he recovers from three separate head knocks that led to emergency surgery to ease pressure on his brain.
    Katoa’s uncle, Reverend Setelo Katoa, spoke with Tongan radio station PMN Tonga on Wednesday, where he confirmed the Melbourne Storm backrower was “recovering well” while expressing gratitude on behalf of the entire family for the messages of support that had been sent to Katoa ever since he was rushed to hospital from Eden Park last Sunday.

    The fallout from Katoa being allowed to take the field after suffering a sickening head knock in the pre-game warm-up of Tonga’s Pacific Championships loss to New Zealand is the focus of the NRL’s sweeping inquest into the incident that also included two further concussions in the ninth and 51st minute of the match.
    “At the moment, he’s doing much better,’’ Reverend Setelo told PMN.

    “He has been moved from the Intensive Care Unit (ICU) to a general ward in the hospital.

    “He’s awake, recovering well, and being looked after by medical staff. The family is very thankful for all the support, love, and prayers from everyone.

    Speaking on behalf of the entire Katoa family, Reverend Setelo expressed his deep gratitude to everyone who has been praying and sending love — including from family, friends, the Tongan community, and people around the world.

    “They’re thankful to God, the medical staff at the hospital, and everyone who has offered prayers and support,’’ he said.

    With Katoa’s immediate playing future in doubt, Reverend Setelo asked for continuing prayer for the NRL star to make a full recovery.

    Radio host of PMN Tonga John Nicholas Pulu translated much of the interview spoken in Tongan to English by stating:

    “Many people have gathered at churches and prayer groups to pray for Elias and his family,’’ Pulu said.
    “The community’s response — both in Tonga and abroad — has been overwhelming.

    “The Reverend emphasised that the family feels the strength and love of everyone supporting them and that their faith remains strong.

    There’s also a message to the Tongan people and supporters: to continue in unity, prayer, and encouragement for Elias and others representing Tonga. The family is truly moved by the outpouring of love and the way people have come together.

    “Supporters from the Melbourne Storm have also sent messages of love and encouragement, saying the whole team and fan base are behind him.’’

    The Storm have been in daily contact with Katoa and his family with the club’s welfare manager Young Tonumaipea flying to Auckland on Monday morning.

    There is no firm timeline on when Katoa will be omitted from hospital in Auckland to return to Melbourne.

    The Storm are eagerly awaiting an outcome from the NRL’s investigation into the traumatic incident, which included Katoa needing to be transported from the interchange bench on a medi-cab with an oxygen mask.
     
    Last edited:
    I'm certainly not excusing the coaches and medical team. They shoulder the blame

    But players need to look out for themselves too. If a 5/8 can pull himself from the game for self preservation, then a player should also do the same if they feel like their head has been snapped back and they feel groggy.

    It's accepted to put your hand up if you've pulled a muscle. But nobody puts their hand up if they are seeing stars. The culture isn't to do so, but needs to change, particularly with everything we read about CTE

    The whole game puts all the onus on the medical staff. Which is fine, but an upshot of that is everyone (players, coaches, refs, fans) expects that it's play on if the medical staff don't say anything. That's not a strong enough system to prevent this sort of thing happening
    This saga is a textbook example of why the independent doctors were brought into contact sports in the first place.

    You cannot trust a player to do what’s in his long term best health interests. You cannot trust the team to do it either.

    Tough guys will pretend they aren’t hurt and teams will do what they need to in order to win.

    It’s disgusting and everyone high enough in the Tonga coaching staff should get sanctioned. If you make coaches liable it will sort itself quick asf.
     

    Why promising young rugby players are choosing league over the sport they grew up playing​


    When teenage rugby prodigy Tom Perkins signed a four-year deal with the Newcastle Knights, he added his voice to a chorus growing too loud for New Zealand Rugby to ignore.
    “[Rugby] league, in my opinion, is more entertaining to watch, and I think it fits my skill set a lot better,” says Perkins, just a week out from beginning preseason with the Knights NRL team.

    Perkins is a 1.96m, 105kg loose forward who has played at the highest levels schoolboy rugby has to offer. Selected in the NZ Secondary Schools side soundly beaten twice by their Australian U18 opponents at the beginning of October, the 18-year-old was in the sights of four Super Rugby franchises and the national system.

    The radar of teenage talent sweeps wider and beeps louder these days. To continue that analogy, one side appears to be hitting its targets more frequently. In October alone, rugby league swooped on three young men who looked to have NZ rugby firmly in their future.

    Harry Inch (NZ Warriors) and Saumaki Saumaki (South Sydney) will join Perkins in the 13-man code next year. Like Perkins, Inch and Saumaki are from the hugely successful Nelson College First XV programme (the trio played together in 2024) and both represented NZ Secondary Schools last year.

    They’re singing from the same song sheet.

    “The game of rugby league excites me and is a lot more entertaining as well,” says Inch, who was linked to the Warriors earlier this month.

    They have something else in common – they’re all managed by experienced dual-code player agent Bruce Sharrock.

    “At times I’m seen as the antichrist that’s coming in and ripping these players out of rugby union,” says Sharrock, before reiterating he favours neither code.

    “My involvement with rugby union has been 27 years and continues to be a dominant part of the business.”

    Among his rugby union clients is All Black Rieko Ioane.

    Sharrock was formerly a director and co-founder of sports management company Esportif International NZ Limited, which was acquired by large international company Wasserman.

    They have league superstars Reece Walsh, Ezra Mam and Hamiso Tabuai-Fidow on their books. Locally, Sharrock represents the likes of Roger Tuivasa-Sheck and Leka Halasima.

    “I’m the only one in the country that is accredited in both and understand both pathways at the elite level,” says Sharrock, who recently relocated to Christchurch.

    Asked about the latest influx of top-tier rugby talent crossing codes, Sharrock is matter-of-fact.

    “First and foremost, there’s nothing new. It’s not like there’s been this big development, and they’ve changed the landscape.”

    He says there are, though, a number of contributing factors that have elevated rugby league, not least of all its growing profile and emphasis on entertainment.

    “I always challenge them as to what code they ultimately want to play because if they’re passionate about it, they’ve got a greater chance of success.

    “I say if there were two games on the television clashing, which one would you watch? More often than not, they’re saying they’ll watch the rugby league.

    “That’s fact. That’s what they tell you,” says Sharrock.

    Of course, there’s a follow-up question.

    “Ultimately, what do you want to do? If you want to change code, do you understand what you’re walking into? They want to play. They love it,” says Sharrock.

    These same conversations were had with Perkins. He gave the same answers.

    “I just love how quick the game is. I think the problem with rugby union, there’s so much stop-start, but league is just super quick. A lot more running with the ball, a lot more aerial work, which I think fits my game a lot better as well,” says Perkins.

    “To be fair, the deals are coming after that conversation, so it’s not ‘there’s a deal in front of me, so I want to grab it’.”

    In the case of Inch and Saumaki, there were deals in front of them 12 months ago.

    “Harry and Saumaki were targeted by rugby league straight out of school. So, the Warriors just missed out on getting both boys,” adds Sharrock.

    Both stayed with rugby union. Both had a change of heart a year later.

    The pathways​

    A common criticism in rugby circles is of its convoluted pathways. It’s a criticism shared by players and administrators. There is little clarity in how a school leaver continues his journey from First XV to the professional game.

    “It’s somewhat cloudy even today as to what your pathway is,” says Sharrock.

    “You have provincial unions who offer development contracts. These can be anywhere from $1 to probably about $2500. The very upper end is $5000. And they effectively have the provincial union providing some infrastructure and high performance for these young men.

    “Tied into that is often the [Super Rugby] franchise is supporting the provincial unions and often leading it to give the young men further high-performance insight through the franchise team, exposure to training days or whatever. Beyond that, you kind of get lost.”

    By contrast, NRL franchises have age group teams that start with under-17s – Harold Matthews Cup. Perkins will start in the SG Ball competition (under-19s) while Inch and Saumaki will get their first taste in Jersey Flegg (under-21s). The next step from there is the New South Wales Cup (reserve grade) before becoming fully-fledged first-grade players.

    “These young guys are going through effectively travelling trans-Tasman, playing in a professional comp, even at the age of 17 through to 21. It’s so clear and well organised,” says Sharrock.

    It’s not uncommon for top-grade NRL coaches to have some oversight on the development of those junior players, providing uniformed feedback.

    “If you’re a young man at 16, who wants to give rugby league a shout, and you’ve got the physical profile that they look for, then they can easily put you into an environment where you could play a competition up until March or April, and still be part of your school’s First XV programme,” says Sharrock.

    “And it’s high-performance elite style sport, and that’s something that rugby doesn’t have in the country for us.

    “Yes, they have the First XV competition, but as we know, there’s a lot of schools that aren’t captured in that.

    “Rugby league is offering them a really good, clear alternative and they’re saying, ‘This is great’. Add to that the financial side of it – it’s chalk and cheese.”

    The money​

    One source who has seen contract negotiations play out between the codes says rugby is “bringing a knife to a gunfight”; such is the disparity between the offers.

    Sharrock says he’s used the same expression.

    If his young clients can go all the way to their club’s first-grade side, their salaries could be comparable with top tier All Blacks.

    “Leka Halasima, look what happened to him. Showed he could play at the highest level at 19 - massive upgrades for four years,” says Sharrock.

    At entry level, the NRL offers more than twice what Super Rugby players earn.

    “The [NRL] top 30 minimum [salary] is now sitting at AU$140,000,” says Sharrock.

    That equates to roughly $160,000 for the upcoming 2026 season.

    And that money is likely to increase when the NRL renegotiates its broadcast rights. The next deal will come into effect in 2028 when the competition expands to 19 teams.

    The current deal is reportedly worth $1.8b - but that could almost double according to some estimates. The flow-on effect would see franchises receive a greater share of those broadcast rights and have salary caps extended – meaning more money for players.

    “That’s just going to raise the stakes yet again. I believe with the new deal, it could be closer to $200,000 minimum,” says Sharrock.

    “The thing that people don’t really understand is the minimum salary for a Super Rugby player has hardly moved in 20 years.”

    Super Rugby franchises must pay their contracted players a minimum of $75,000 per year but they can pay up to a maximum of $195,000 per year. NZR can step in to top up certain players’ salaries beyond that.

    The opportunities in rugby league can also be multi-faceted. In Perkins’ case, he’ll live in brand-new custom-built accommodation with other like-minded young hopefuls and study at the University of Newcastle.

    “That’s all taken care of, which is pretty awesome as well,” says Perkins, who will study commerce.

    The players​

    Perkins’ story is something of a ‘sliding doors’ moment.

    When the whistle blew to start the First XV pre-season clash with St Thomas of Canterbury College at Hanmer Springs in late April, he had no idea of the eyes he was about to catch.

    Stood inconspicuously in the crowd that day was renowned talent scout, Peter O’Sullivan. His eyes have previously discovered Billy Slater, Greg Inglis and Israel Folau as schoolboys.

    “I watched the game for about five minutes and thought, ‘Wow, who’s this big blonde number 8?’. I found someone in the crowd that knew him and knew his dad and introduced myself at halftime,” says O’Sullivan.

    O’Sullivan, Newcastle’s head of recruitment, was in Christchurch for the Knights’ round 8 clash with the Warriors. The doors slid for Perkins when O’Sullivan decided to drive almost two hours to watch a game on a whim.

    “I wasn’t going to watch anyone in particular. Sometimes they’re the best outcomes.Sometimes you just got to get lucky and be at the ground.”

    The luck was shared by both parties. Perkins now finds himself heading to a club that is in a rebuild, having sacked their first-grade coach and lost a couple of international forwards. Among them Kai Pearce-Paul, an Englishman with a very similar build to Perkins.

    “I think he’s more athletic than Kai Pearce-Paul, to be fair. He’s well put together. He moves well, beautiful balance.

    “I definitely think he could play an edge given time in the NRL, but he’d certainly be able to play in the middle as well. He looks a special talent to me,” says O’Sullivan.

    Harry Inch’s u-turn caught a few by surprise after a year that saw him get a taste of the Crusaders environment, including game time during their pre-season fixture against the Blues at Kirwee.

    A year after spurning the Warriors’ advances, the curly mullet-wearing playmaker reconsidered. Farm-raised, Inch’s explanation is suitably agricultural.

    “If a farmer waits for the perfect weather to sow his crop, he will never harvest anything. I felt like it was now or never, and these opportunities don’t come often,” says Inch.

    Inch was a schoolboy star in the 10 jersey. If he is seen as a half by the Warriors, then his transition will be the toughest of the three. Not that Inch minds.

    “I feel excited to give a new code a good crack and look forward to the new challenges that come with it,” says Inch.

    Saumaki Saumaki is a powerhouse loose forward who is strong with ball-in-hand and devastating in defence. He’s an awkward shape in professional rugby – probably too short to continue his career at number 8 or blindside flanker, but he’s the perfect build for rugby league.

    The Rabbitohs certainly think so, inking a two-year deal.

    The future​

    As it stands, the professional rugby league options available to NZ’s best and brightest young players far outweigh the equivalent in rugby union. There are six Super Rugby franchises based in NZ. Playing anywhere else makes them ineligible for the All Blacks and the bumper payday that comes with the black jersey.

    By comparison, there are 17 NRL clubs. For now.

    In 2027, the Perth Bears will enter the NRL and they’re already actively trying to recruit.

    The following year, the Papua New Guinea Chiefs will be the competition’s 19th team. They’ll be offering big money to import players – tax-free.

    The battle for the signatures of young talent is only going to intensify. Sharrock believes there are lessons for NZR to learn from the NRL.

    “It’s cut-throat. If they don’t like you after 12 months or two years, we’ll have a conversation about how we get you out of here. And dare I say to me that’s what rugby needs to start bringing in.

    “You’ve got All Blacks on well-paid contracts who are really just taking money. Start trading, start doing what the world does. NBA, NFL, soccer, rugby league, they trade.

    “At the end of the day, if you’re not worth what we’re now paying you, let’s have a conversation about an exit.

    “There are competitions in France, Japan - if you’re allowed an early release, they would use the stock that we’ve got here. You would possibly get a transfer fee, make some money out of it, carry on.

    “Having been involved in the rugby league world for as long, that’s the difference. It’s a commodity,” says Sharrock.

    Despite leaving the sport for greener pastures, Perkins is nothing but appreciative of the opportunities rugby union has given him.

    He’s given it all he had since he was a 5-year-old playing rippa.

    But next season will be different – and that season starts soon.

    “I’ve heard rugby league preseason is pretty tough, but I’m up for the challenge. I’m pretty excited,” says Perkins.

     
    We don’t have a chance of signing Linnane if he doesn’t have the two ACL injuries. He’s a high reward low risk signing and he looks like a very similar player to Metcalf. Don’t think he’s going to be ready next year but we have four experienced halves for next season.

    Linnane, Cleary, Hanson, Thompson the idea is right. Sign young Australian halves and hope you hit with one of them.
     
    People like SJ and those on the sidelines probably feel a bit conflicted that they didn’t take the footage or point out to the Tongan staff of what had occurred now if they didn’t see it and that’s why he was cleared to play? Can only take a positive that someone hasn’t lost their lives, but their career could very much be a factor and his length of time out? This is where nrl are intertwined because storm pays his salary and was he upgraded or in line to be? Because he’s been the form second row for a couple of years running now. Lots of possibilities if how there could be fallout and between who? First and foremost I’m sure is getting Katoa sound and stable though but then it likely turns to a blame game
    I don’t buy Tongas stance that they didn’t see it/weren’t aware of it- there’s clearly a trainer right there in the footage. It stinks of staff covering their arses when they clearly messed up badly
     
    Was at the game and blown away by the atmosphere

    When the MMT anthem started everyone around our area (and I suspect the stadium) who were wearing red started singing

    At the end of it I feared that the NZ anthem would be performed in silence but how wrong that was as the same folk who had just sung their anthem joined with those of us singing the NZ anthem and it was louder than the MMT anthem

    It struck home to me that the Pacific Islanders who have made NZ home are as much NZers as they Islanders.

    The kiwis scored the red flags were waved with vigour, the Tongans defended well the red flags were waved with vigour, the Tongans scored the crowd erupted.

    A Tongan supporter 2 rows in front of us had a humongous Tongan flag that for good portions of the game obscured our view as he waved it whenever some action took place but I choose not to ask him to be “more respectful” of others for two reasons- 1) he was just enjoying his day at the footie supporting his team/s 2) he was a big bugger!!

    Throughout the game there was spontaneous singing of Tongan songs (or I thought they were).

    I’ve been to many grand finals, numerous rugby tests, Presidents Cup golf tournaments, Commonwealth Games etc. but I’ve never been in a crowd with as much atmosphere as was at Eden Park on Sunday.

    If you ever get an opportunity to attend a game where a Pacific Island team is playing go, you won’t be disappointed
     
    I didn’t see the training incident but did the medical staff see it happen at the time?

    Could it have happened without any official knowing, seen as it wasn’t within the game?

    I've heard a few different things, but I think it was Flanno who said the team doctors saw it but didn't seem it necessary to complete a hia check. Which is pretty bizarre as he looked like he was knocked out. If you're not checking that you're checking absolutely zero
     
Back
Top Bottom