Tanwah in 2025 outplayed the following former warriors halves
Kodi in his warriors version
Ata hingano
Mason lino
Seas O’Sullivan warriors version
Ash Taylor
Ronald volkman
I think the criticism of Boyd overlooks the fact that if his issue is confidence (don't disagree) that time playing the game will resolve this, especially under the type of coach we have.
I think he gets written off wayyy too prematurely, confidence or the lack thereof is not a permanent irreversible deficit - the world is full of great achievers who suffered confidence issues coming up through their rise.
The problem really is the Warriors expectations based off past experience, this is a club that has failed to turn around confidence issues in players and almost without exception sent them to the scrap heap where they have never recovered. Ergo the fans see someone choke in a game and they're written off forever.
This year Ben fecking Hunt won a title.
The thing about Boyd is that he has superior core skills of a seven, his tool kit of variation with his field kicking is decent, his passing game is solid, his playing at the line is good.
He has to fix his freeze under pressure. It may well be in his best interest to find a club where he is behind a dominant forward pack (like he enjoys in the NSW cup) which will lessen the pressure on his overall game and he will become a very fine NRL half. But then....aren't we the turning into the type of club that will have a dominant forward pack?
I think Boyd will be a very good half back one day. I also think it is fair to ask the questions around whether we need to be the club that takes the long term risk with a gamble on Boyd. And I might be wrong, he might never get there, but then can level that censure (never getting there) at any player we have coming up.
Lets not forget CHT has had a rocky career in FG, he is solid now, but he has had bags of shit too coming up - the solid player that is our six did not magically turn into one, he was given time and investment, he was allowed to play shit games and still get picked till he found his role/ and most importantly found the right partner.