i dunno, i know cleary made the call leading up to the tigers game a month ago that he wants Guttenbiel to be on the bench so he can sub wiki (for leadership value) and thats exactly whats been happening since. and its working great! guttenbiel has been playing out of his skin, offloads are sticking, new lease on life you could say
yeah it has been working great and at the end of the day does it really matter too much. they both are in the squad each week for now and one starts while the other is on the bench and both are playing quite well so it is working for sure.