General Your team for 2013

  • Thread starter Lord Gnome of Howick MBE
  • Start date
Lord Gnome of Howick MBE

Lord Gnome of Howick MBE

1) A fully fit and rested Kevin Locke
2) .............
3) Dane Neilson
4) Konrad Hurrell after a full off-season on defending at centre
5) Manu
6) Carlos
7) Sean
8) Rapira (until he gets injured)
9) Freind
10) Matalino
11) Martell
12) Mannering
13) Ikahihifo

14) TL
15) Packer
16) Liliman
17) Taylour

Carlos and Sean know each other's games backwards, you would know if a couple of weeks if it works or if its distastrous.

I feel for poor little Billy Toupo, but he aint a winger (but then again, neither is Slimey?)
 
Hitman82

Hitman82

1) A fully fit and rested Kevin Locke
2) .............
3) Dane Neilson
4) Konrad Hurrell after a full off-season on defending at centre
5) Manu
6) Carlos
7) Sean
8) Rapira (until he gets injured)
9) Freind
10) Matalino
11) Martell
12) Mannering
13) Ikahihifo

14) TL
15) Packer
16) Liliman
17) Taylour

Carlos and Sean know each other's games backwards, you would know if a couple of weeks if it works or if its distastrous.

I feel for poor little Billy Toupo, but he aint a winger (but then again, neither is Slimey?)
1 Locke
2 Tupou / someone new
3 Tuimavavae (a strong runner who can actually set up his winger)
4 Hurrell
5 Nielsen (to help educate young Hurrell)
6 TL
7 Johnson
8 Matulino
9 Friend
10 Package
11 Martel
12 Ben Henry/Taylor (I don't want both in the team along with Mannering)
13 Simon Mannering

14 Ikahihifo (adds something other than tacklebotting)
15 Sam Rapira
16 Lillyman
17 Vatuvei / Lousi (whichever one is looking more ruthless)
 
eX | Machina

eX | Machina

1 Locke
2 someone new << speed, jumps high, catches ball, can adequately play centre and fullback ie. is not a second rower
3 Hurrell
4 Tuimavave
5 Nielsen
6 Johnson
7 Godinet
8 Sam Rapira
9 Friend
10 Matulino
11 Mateo < 80 minutes
12 Mannering
13 Lowrie

14 Ropati < Lock
15 Vatuvei < Second row
16 Lillyman
17 Packer



Potential is just that, potential. There is no substitute for experience.

Injury/form cover: TL, Steve Rapira, Taylor, Henry, Mara, Lousi, Lousi, Tupou, Fisiiahi, Omar << these guys can play Vulcans against big boppers and fight/earn a spot in first grade. There should be a minimum Vulcans probationary period before an Under 20's player plays top grade. Unless the player is the "next big thing" like a Taumalolo

Edited to accommodate for Todd Lowrie.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
ajofbrisbane

ajofbrisbane

1 Locke
2 Tupou / someone new
3 Tuimavavae (a strong runner who can actually set up his winger)
4 Hurrell
5 Nielsen (to help educate young Hurrell)
6 TL
7 Johnson
8 Matulino
9 Friend
10 Package
11 Martel
12 Ben Henry/Taylor (I don't want both in the team along with Mannering)
13 Simon Mannering

14 Ikahihifo (adds something other than tacklebotting)
15 Sam Rapira
16 Lillyman
17 Vatuvei / Lousi (whichever one is looking more ruthless)

Why do you want the club that has bought a centre to then play him at wing?
I don't think he is the greatest attacking centre running around but his defensive pattern is pretty good....
 
Lord Gnome of Howick MBE

Lord Gnome of Howick MBE

I think that every team needs a Taylor/Luck/Benry type player - our trouble is we have three of them (four when Mannering decides to join the club.)
 
fanrrior

fanrrior

I'm with you on Taylor fanrrior. Maybe he is trying too hard to fill somebody's shoes! Maybe he is flat-out exhausted!, but his apparent superhuman efforts are reaping very few rewards.
I think it's because he doesn't offer anything we don't already have. His attitude on defence is great but his technique is poor imo. Whilst he generally might make a lot of tackles most of the time it is bordering on flop because the other bloke has already done the hard bit. If even that because as we saw against the Sharks they were just standing straight in tackles offloading when they felt like it.

For me Ben Henry and Sebastian Ikihihifo (spelling?) will be better prospects.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Hitman82

Hitman82

Why do you want the club that has bought a centre to then play him at wing?
I don't think he is the greatest attacking centre running around but his defensive pattern is pretty good....

Fair question!

While Dane is currently playing as a centre, he is actually a centre/wing utility and is effective in both roles.

Basically, I want him beside Hurrell.

Nielsen is an experienced player who has played in the best-drilled team in the NRL, and the champion Queensland origin team. His experience would be invaluable for a young guy like Hurrell, helping him learn to defend and communicate properly and offering a quality finisher who won't do retarded stuff like over-running the ball or getting bundled into touch during every other run.

From the look of Tuimavavae, we need him in the NRL side. He's a tall, rangy, strong player with great ball skills and a decent level of aggression about him. He's not going to displace a Kiwi's half in T.L, so he gets the centre spot.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
ajofbrisbane

ajofbrisbane

Fair question!

While Dane is currently playing as a centre, he is actually a centre/wing utility and is effective in both roles.

Basically, I want him beside Hurrell.

Nielsen is an experienced player who has played in the best-drilled team in the NRL, and the champion Queensland origin team. His experience would be invaluable for a young guy like Hurrell, helping him learn to defend and communicate properly and offering a quality finisher who won't do retarded stuff like over-running the ball or getting bundled into touch during every other run.

From the look of Tuimavavae, we need him in the NRL side. He's a tall, rangy, strong player with great ball skills and a decent level of aggression about him. He's not going to displace a Kiwi's half in T.L, so he gets the centre spot.

Fair enough.....i think Neilsen is a better defensive centre than attacking one....he will much needed experience to the edge....
As for Carlos i think he is viewed as more of a "long term" replacement at 5/8 with T/L being used there for a season or 2 until carlos finds his groove.
 
Dankokoro 2.0

Dankokoro 2.0

I think that every team needs a Taylor/Luck/Benry type player - our trouble is we have three of them (four when Mannering decides to join the club.)

Totally agree... It seems silly to complain about defensive orientated players when it's our defense that's been so shit this season, but it annoys me how involved these guys are on attack. What's worse is our attacking structure is so shit and is so lacking in depth, these guys are normally standing still when they receive the ball.. then their choice is to a) run straight at the line and be met by 2-3 defenders, or shuffle it on to the next guy who's more or less standing still who will have the same 2 options.

Mannering, Benry, and Taylor are all going to be playing big minutes next year which is not an exciting prospect. Not that i have a problem with Simon - except for the fact that he is extremely ineffective on attack and gets the ball far too often... except for that. At least he can offload. Taylor i think actually has the ability to develop an attacking game and he's shown signs that he has some skill with ball in hand, but he (or the coaches) don't seem to be trying to develop it. Benry is at best adequate injury cover in my eyes.. as a club i think we should have much higher standards than this guy. If we don't have anyone better, then we need to look at signing someone.

Not so long ago the question was whether Michael Lucks place in the team coule be justified because he was a one-dimensional tacklebot. Now we have 3 guys in the team that don't do much except tackle.. I just worry that Bluey is more than happy with these guys because they train hard and have good attitudes etc. We need more than 1 backrower that is capable of sparking something in attack ffs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
ryno

ryno

Time for fish to make a move permanently to wing. Would then have an offseason training in that position, can trial there etc etc.

We would then have (if he goes well) a fast winger who can then back up full back if need be.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
ryno

ryno

On ropati, just too many injuries and is just too much of a liability on defense.

Is a real nice guy and I think he would do well mentoring other players etc but I don't think he is up to the nrl level anymore.

Hope he proves me wrong though.
 
Lord Gnome of Howick MBE

Lord Gnome of Howick MBE

Or

1) Kevin Locke
2) Konrad Hurrell
3) Dane Neilson
4) Jerome Ropati
5) Manu
6) Carlos
7) Sean
8) Rapira (until he gets injured)
9) Freind
10) Matalino
11) Martell
12) Mannering
13) Ikahihifo

14) TL
15) Packer
16) Liliman
17) Taylour

And $1m under the salary cap.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
ajofbrisbane

ajofbrisbane

Or

1) Kevin Locke
2) Konrad Hurrell
3) Dane Neilson
4) Jerome Ropati
5) Manu
6) Carlos
7) Sean
8) Rapira (until he gets injured)
9) Freind
10) Matalino
11) Martell
12) Mannering
13) Ikahihifo

14) TL
15) Packer
16) Liliman
17) Taylour

And $1m under the salary cap.

throw the $million at Bellamy.....
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
wallacenz

wallacenz

Or

1) Kevin Locke
2) Konrad Hurrell
3) Dane Neilson
4) Jerome Ropati
5) Manu
6) Carlos
7) Sean
8) Rapira (until he gets injured)
9) Freind
10) Matalino
11) Martell
12) Mannering
13) Ikahihifo

14) TL
15) Packer
16) Liliman
17) Taylour

And $1m under the salary cap.
The Ropati at centre of 2007/2008, definitely. Old Jerome, I dont know. Hes looked so bad at centre in the last couple of years, hes looked like a better fullback. A couple of years ago everyone was calling for his head until he got moved to fullback and all was forgiven.
 
Lord Gnome of Howick MBE

Lord Gnome of Howick MBE

Well, Hurrell/Neilson/Ropati doesn't go into two centre spots.......
 

Similar threads

mt.wellington
Replies
25
Views
5K
ajofbrisbane
ajofbrisbane
BeastMode
Replies
342
Views
34K
wizards rage
wizards rage
Replies
61
Views
3K
Skinny_Ravs82
Replies
14
Views
893
Jesbass_old
danyooll
Replies
7
Views
567
jonno
jonno

Last Game

08 May

10 - 29
3.9 Total Avg Rating
2.2 Your Avg Rating

Highest Rated Player

Lowest Rated Player

Compiled from 13 ratings