General Vulcans hammered

¿N. ig-mah¿

Warriors 1st Grader
May 1, 2012
6,081
Invercargill
Doesn't help that Bluey took 2 players out of contention.

Fish was named as Warriors 18th man but never travelled and Sam Lousi took the spot and plane ticket. I think it is a bit tough on the Vulcans when important players are ruled out due to selection at 18th man, even though Bluey has no intention to play them. The only reason I can see for Fish being named was to give the impression that Locke may not have been 100% recovered.
 

Kaizen

NSW Cup Player
May 15, 2012
290
The NRL takes presedence over the Vulcans team though. Given a choice which side would any of these players want to play for?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Swanley

¿N. ig-mah¿

Warriors 1st Grader
May 1, 2012
6,081
Invercargill
The NRL takes presedence over the Vulcans team though. Given a choice which side would any of these players want to play for?
Given a choice, I would assume they would rather play footy than sit on the sideline while the coach tries to play cunning mind games with oppositions. I have no problem with a player being selected as 18th man if he is a genuine chance of covering in case of injury, but Bluey seems to use it as a reward, while replacing the player. Or with Lousi getting it, I'm guessing it is a little teaser, similar to what he has given Godinet this year, but it could amount to nothing.
 

Kaizen

NSW Cup Player
May 15, 2012
290
Chance to play top grade NRL vs. certainty to play park footy. If it were me i'd take the chance to play NRL if i'm serious about my football.
 

surfin

Warriors 1st Grader
May 9, 2012
5,288
Coromandel
The 18th man warms up with the team incase a player does something to themselves in that time. It can and does happen so they are a chance of playing right up until kickoff.
 

¿N. ig-mah¿

Warriors 1st Grader
May 1, 2012
6,081
Invercargill
The 18th man warms up with the team incase a player does something to themselves in that time. It can and does happen so they are a chance of playing right up until kickoff.
That isn't quite what I'm talking about. Fish was named on Tuesday as 18th man. That meant he was ruled out of the Vulcans. My opinion of why Bluey named his was to bamboozle Ivan into thinking Locke was a chance of not playing. He then took Sam Lousi to Australia. Fish was never going to play. Why name him?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Est95

OMG

Warriors 1st Grader
May 18, 2012
3,990
Churchur
The 18th man warms up with the team incase a player does something to themselves in that time. It can and does happen so they are a chance of playing right up until kickoff.
Pettybourne 2 weeks ago did his calf in the warm up, it's crucial to have good cover at 18th man and Fish was carrying an injury at the end of last weeks game that he might not of got over..
 

surfin

Warriors 1st Grader
May 9, 2012
5,288
Coromandel
Often with all the clubs the team named on the tuesday doesn't resemble the playing squad on the weekend, especially for a monday game. I wouldn't think who gets named by the opposition has too much to do with the other teams build up, as even a couple of different players would have minimal affect on a game plan.
 

Miket12

Warriors 1st Grader
Apr 20, 2012
7,664
That isn't quite what I'm talking about. Fish was named on Tuesday as 18th man. That meant he was ruled out of the Vulcans. My opinion of why Bluey named his was to bamboozle Ivan into thinking Locke was a chance of not playing. He then took Sam Lousi to Australia. Fish was never going to play. Why name him?
From information I've heard from within the club, it was hoped that Fish's knee was going to come right before the team travelled (given it was a Monday night game) but when he hadn't recovered enough, he was pulled from the 18th man spot. It was his injury, not a tactical decision from Bluey, which meant he didn't go over to Penrith.
 

Miket12

Warriors 1st Grader
Apr 20, 2012
7,664
BTW, Fish has been named in the Vulcans for this week to play the Magpies - but I've heard, unofficially, that this is subject to a fitness test on his knee.
 

Nekminit

Waterboy
May 17, 2012
47
Botany Auckland NZ
That isn't quite what I'm talking about. Fish was named on Tuesday as 18th man. That meant he was ruled out of the Vulcans. My opinion of why Bluey named his was to bamboozle Ivan into thinking Locke was a chance of not playing. He then took Sam Lousi to Australia. Fish was never going to play. Why name him?
Why name him? Coz the fish was 1st choice as 18th man, the team was named on Tuesday but did not travel until sunday 5 days later! Fish would have been given most of that 5 days to prove his fitness.