Mosh said:
Stacey Jones, Ali Lauiti-iti, Clinton Toopi, Sione Faumuina, Motu Tony. There we have expansive players who I believe were at their peaks playing at home.
I really think your theory is quite absurd. Its all due to coaching and application of players. Tevita Latu was used as a rotten apple here, a few minor incidents and he probably was shown the toilet a few times as thats what he would be cleaning if he wanted to stay at the club. However, at the Sharks they probably told Latu he would be on the bench every game. That makes all the difference to a youngster when someone has faith in you. You really do not want to let them down.
Not a theory Mosh. A still-forming opinion on the majority and not set in stone.
I'm talking overall structure of the sport and not just coaching. Of course it comes into it but my impression is that the stakes are higher, earlier in Aussie so the mental capacity to want and have to succeed is greater. Some of our juniors are look like they are actually
designed to play football yet some pissweak aussie performs better. I think it is too easy too fast and then they bugger off or burn when hit by expectations.
IMO previous locals seemed to be too mentally weak to be professional athletes. The Kiwi side has how many players that performed well here first? The locals coming out through the junior systems now seem better equiped to handle it due to earlier professional exposure. When brought on slowly, as the dev team seems to be, the trend will continue to your opinion but I believe from the past until now, or very soon, my "absurd" suggestion has a basis.
On your examples.
Stacey Jones - No comment needed as is a cut above any we'll see for a while.
Ali Lauititi - Fantastic player. Fell of the boil during a team low and didn't get the opportunity to carry on. Don't care about the reasons. Mentally not hard enough.
Clinton Toopi - 2 good years. That's it. Relied on Ali. Ali went, so did his form.
Sione Faumuina - Good player but plays like a hero. Left first and saw what the NRL was like elsewhere but preferred being home. Fair enough.
Motu Tony - Decent player, but not a team one presumably. Same as Ali, for reasons I care not, mentally couldn't handle it.