Your in it now. Sorry but thems the rules.No he isn't, not if we are talking about Rugby League. Kata is the form one on one defensive centre in the NRL. They have been quiet on attack that side, but there is little to no quality ball getting out there.
Edit: I have since seen you and Danpatmac get into a bit of a debate about this, leave me out of it... but you're wrong and Danpatmac is right.
Kata can put a shot on for sure. But since when has being the best at one micro skill been something to shout about.
And how many times does he have to run in completely the wrong direction before he becomes a bad defender.
The days of keeping guys in the top team because they do one thing really well, and the other 100 things in ways that school girls laugh at, are over.
Unless we get loads of injuries of course.