Pick Your Team Pick Your Team 2017 Rnd 8 - Storm vs Warriors

Status
Not open for further replies.
Dec 19, 2012
264
Pick Your Team 2017 Rnd 8 - Storm vs Warriors


After the Round 7 game against the Canberra Raiders at GIO Stadium do you want to see any changes for the Round 8 game against the Melbourne Storm at AAMI Stadium?

Promotions?
Demotions?
Any new injury concerns?
Any returning players?
Any tweaks to the bench?

Bear in mind this game is on a Tuesday night.

Discuss...
 

Inruin

.... LOADING ....
Contributor
May 19, 2012
7,693
Auckland
RTS
CNK
KATA
BLAKE
Fusitua
FORAN
SJ
LILLYMAN
LUKE
GAVET
HOFFMAN
BUNTY
MANNERING

LISONE
VETE
SAO
GUBB I guess

Assuming mutts is still out and Bodene suspended
 

ryno

1st Grade Fringe
May 8, 2012
2,482
1. RTS
2. Pauga
3. Ayshford
4. Fusitua
5. CNK
6. Foran
7. Johnson
8. Gavet
9. Luke
10. Lilllyman
11. Afoa
12. Hoffman
13. Mannering

Bench
Kata
Lisone
Vete
P. Sipley
 

jonno

Warriors 1st Grader
Jul 13, 2014
9,804
Battering rams on the wings helps make meters up the middle, but they don't help us win on the score board. Better off with wingers who can score long range tries, so you don't need as many meters up the middle to attack the opposition line.

Footy 101 surely.

I like Maumalo tho. He'll make a great edge forward one day if he's lucky...
 
  • Like
Reactions: bruce and Hadyn

wallacenz

Warriors 1st Grader
May 7, 2012
7,240
Is Fusitua a centre? he was invisible today. Would he be more valuable on the wing? hes good under the high ball, a good finisher, and hes big unit to carry the ball back. Maybe the Warriors should look at a mid season purchase of a centre
 

Brox001

Warriors Bench Player
May 16, 2015
86
Maumalo is not a long term wing prospect. We need to look to the future and blood a traditional winger, who actually scores tries and doesn't make many mistakes - when was the last time we had one of them? Laumape probably....

We have to sort out our bench. Sao has to go, he is not an NRL quality forward. Roache provided no impact. Afoa has to come back, Hingano as an impact player on the bench.
 

koolkat

1st Grade Fringe
May 18, 2012
2,776
Nelson
Wish we still had wells,.the dude had wheels.that qualifying final he out ran everyone.just beat people with speed but apparently he wasn't big enough.fuck off you dicks.would of put him ahead of Manu,and ken.
 
Last edited:

AlexM

1st Grade Fringe
Feb 19, 2017
1,452
Bunty in for bodene if suspension
Mutz for ligi or gub.

Ken & sol need to work on there d
 

ttkk19

1st Grade Fringe
Sep 21, 2013
745
What a dilemma we've found ourselves in.

We've recruited/retained an under strength and under sized forward pack that struggles to assert its dominance over other teams.

As a result we're relying on our outside backs to help set our forward platform rather than adding punch when needed.

So instead of targeting tired forwards with pace and footwork and creating line breaks and second phase, what they're doing is taking one-out hit ups early on in our sets like a bunch of battering rams...

And because of the frequency at which they're doing this, they're getting more fatigued than they usually would which is causing various lapses in concentration and repeated errors.

In turn, these repeated errors are forcing more pressure onto our already struggling forward pack and so repeats the circle of life.

This is the reason Maumalo's job is safe. This is the reason CNK can't get a look in. The sooner our forward pack starts dominating other teams the sooner we can get in some speed and finesse on the edges and start looking like a real footy team again.

Therefore, I'd like to see the following changes:
- Matulino in (if fit) for Sao
- Vete in for Gubb
- Bunty in for Thompson (if suspended)
- Possibly a reserve forward like Satai or a Sipley for a short 15min stint
- 4 prop bench with regular rotations to keep the intensity high

If we can start to gain some consistent forward dominance or even parity (over a 2-3 week period) I'd then look at bringing in some speed with the likes of CNK (for Maumalo) and Roach (bench).

Just to make my point clear, I think wingers and outside backs should only be used as battering rams in tough times when you're in a real grind and your forwards are out on their heels, as can be seen with Manu in the Kiwis or in State of Origin games. I don't think that should be our default setting to be used for 80min week in and week out all season. It takes far too much out of our backline and dulls our strike weapons.
 
Last edited:

BlaqAdam

Warriors Bench Player
Mar 5, 2016
183
Our fowards were a lil under sized today but i seriously thought they played well. However, i was not impressed with the backs AT ALL lol. i felt Foran was completely absent throughout that second half, Kata and Maumalos defense was EMBARRASSING. Pressure got to RTS as he was forced to take the ball on a lil more. Shuans defence here and there was below average. i just feel like our backs could not hold on to the ball at all. few unfortunate errors from Mannering and Thompson didnt help either. Our entire team found it hard to contain the offloads too, no one taking ball on tackles up top... I say we use new centers and look at bringing someone like Charnze in... Roach should not have of come on and we look at putting Bunty in for either Sao or at 18th man. We got enough punch, i just reckon we need to hold on to the dam ball !! lol. .....

Also that s the worst ref ive seen in awhile.
 

Toopi is King

1st Grade Fringe
Mar 20, 2016
405
Otorohanga
If I try to be completely objective and remove all emotion from my critique, I would have to say that it wasn't a bad performance, as we did come up against one of the top teams in red hot form and only got beat by 12. There were some areas of improvement required, but nothing I felt that was dramatically bad, so all and all I would give it a pass mark and still good signs for the rest of the season.

Could you imagine if the Raiders continue to play like they do, then they will be the minor premiers, with a for and against better than any has ever been in the NRL

Whoops this was supposed to go in the other thread, sorry
 
Status
Not open for further replies.