What I think has gone down hill is our composure and defense since
SK.
SK's sinking was his lack of offensive playbook imo. He got our completions and defense on point, but just never implemented an effective offense, although I thought that was coming 2019, but that potentially top 4 spine was shattered by Georgie Pies demeaning way of asking for more for his money (even though the playmaker was consistently doing a top tier #6 job every week, it seems management confused that with providing a miracle individual game every week).
Strangely the loss to Manly imo was our best defensive effort this year.
I dont think anyone is panicking, we are just crap at structured offense and that is largely on the 5/8th and 9. That hasnt improved since
Kodi has been at the club or since
Egan has been at the club.
Kodi will know what the club is doing, hed be pretty dumb if he didn't. But I think he could save himself by giving hooker a shot. Although I think the club would be mad to continue paying $650k for him.
Whilst there is no panic, if we do not turn things around immediately, we will be 2 from 7, nearly 3rd of season gone and sitting near bottom of the table. St George and Melb look like 2 and 3 in the comp to me, a win seems futile, but player and positional changes could turn that around. And after the next 2 weeks our draw softens up for most of the season imo.
We have flogged dead horses for over 26 years and Im pretty tired of it, especially when we are 2 key positions away from a top 4 team again, but those positions control both the go forward and the execution of our offense, so they have to change.
Despite a number of our star signings, our forwards are still gaining huge metres every set, I dont remember a year where I was confident we would be close to the redzone by the end of most sets no matter where it started from.
Those close losses remind me of 2017, we just do not have the roster to close out games. How we loss to manly is absurd. Our forwards are providing SOOO many redzone opportunities, but we do not have the right spine combination to Ice them. And without changes at 9 and 6, we will not get the most out of our new offensive FB.
A good to great 6 and 9, and next year with all our star players fit, I thnk we are on the cusp (like at end of 2018), of being a top 4 and legacy team. But we must not accept less than a top 4 spine to be a top 4 team. I think Brown can coach a top 4 team, hes not a great coach, but I dont think he will strangle our offense. The team will make him look good.