In my head your comment is pretty tongue in cheek, so I'll go with that. Seems fair, why risk a potential failure when you can stick with the safe bet of certain failure.
I rate Monty Betham for his ability to punch opposition forwards when it was legal, so yes my comment was tongue in cheek.
However I do respect
SK and although he is very conservative he has been there and done that enough to know what makes a first grade forward. Betham was a team mate of
SK's so might have some inside information.
That is not saying the Sipley's are on the outer but
SK was trained under Warren Ryan whose attitude to good players was to treat them tough to see what they were really made of. Gary Freeman wrote about that in his book.
SK did that with CNK who really showed what he was made of and looks to be a regular in FG now.
It wouldn't surprise me to see the Sipleys do the same, and if they don't
SK obviously doesn't rate them.
CNK's foot work for the Try / no Try in the corner was spookily reminiscent of Shaun Hope's footwork and finish....total flash back.
Wiping a tear of nostalgia away, Sean Hoppe was a bit bigger than CNK but I do like the comparison. I remember the night at MSS when even before I had got to my seat Sean had run over the top of Willie Carne no less to score in the tunnel corner.
Steve from your managemnt degree day please change your selection poilcy away from hierachy to performance.
I am sure
SK remembers management 101, but I bet he remembers what Warren Ryan taught him even more. Ryan was a control freak school teacher, but neither a pussy nor a business manager.