General Not so "legend" Warriors?

mosh_old

Guest
Who are your "not so legend" warriors.

I think one of the worst signings was Pethybridge, and maybe Ridge when you look at the time he spent off the field. But Ridge was my favourite player he was awesome.
 

macdad_old

Guest
disagree with ellis call, he wasnt too shabby for us & there were many worse! ridge, slightly agree for same reason, hardly there & money wise, took club 2 cleaners.
andy platt (way past it) ditto manoa thompson. ilthink of a few more later, tiredaz!
 

Mattlore Dee._old

Guest
Platt tried, just didn't have any knees left
Pethybridge had some good moments
Ellis had more good moments

Moana...got nothing good to say about him :D

Um...worst ever...tough call, theres been so many
 

Mattlore Dee._old

Guest
Shane was a handy player, you could chuck him anywhere

course he wasn't really any good in any position
 

PHANTOM MENACE_old

Guest
YOU COULD ALMOST NAME TO TEAMS OF WARRIORS WORST EVER SIGNINGS.
SE'E SOLOMONA
GAVIN HILL
WILLIE SWANN
MANOA THOMPSON
DENNIS BETTS
SCOTT PETHYBRIDGE
SCOTT COXON
JUSTIN MORGAN
MATT JOBSON ???????????????

THE LIST GOES ON AND ON
 

BulldogMike_old

Guest
You could start one for the worst Warriors moments too. Two forward passes stand out for mine, the first was Jason Bell (i think that was his name) on a wet night against the Raiders, and the second Terry Hermannson against the Sharks. Two of the biggest forward passes I've seen, unbelievable.
Brings back great memories of the bad old days.....
 

Mattlore Dee._old

Guest
Yeah, Jason Bell, bought over here thru our dev. deal with the Newtown jets
 

PHANTOM MENACE_old

Guest
GEE WE HAVE SPENT SOME LOOSE MONEY.
SHARKEY ROBINSON IS ANOTHER THAT COMES TO MIND
 

Sinbad_old

Guest
Sharkey didn't sign on just trainined and played on a temp contract.

Marc Ellis was top try scorerin his year.

My pick is John Carlaw Or Oderidin. Oderrider was a total waste of time. So highly rated and didn't do much. His airness Henry jumps higher.

Would also agree about Ridgey, we signed him 1 year too late.

John Kerwin could have been good but also 1 year too late. Dan the Man has the idea , sign em early.
 

Thierry Henry

Guest
You couldn't really say Marc Ellis, he made the Kiwi side while playing for us and was, as mentioned, our top tryscorer one year.

Also I think Lee Oudenryn stayed around too long to be considered one of our worst. And Odell Manuel had some ability, what happened to him?

There are players who had very brief careers who could make this list, such as Jonathon Smith or Anthony SeuSeu.

What about that guy Docherty (sp??). The blonde goalkicker?
 

Mattlore Dee._old

Guest
Douherty! he was okay for being plucked out of Bartercard Cup...back in the days when the standard wasn't very good

he wouldn't of got much $$$
 

Ferris

Guest
Was it Carl Doherty from Mt Albert club? From memory, he was also a newbie to league (ie had not been playing all that long in the scheme of things). To be fair, he did have a boot on him which was just one of the things the Warriors lacked at the time.

My not so legend would have to be Brady Malam. Dunno why, he just didn't seem to offer much and was the worst of a seemingly bad bunch.
 

Mattlore Dee._old

Guest
Yeah, Carl Doherty from Mt Albert Lions sounds about right...

Is Malam still playing? I know he went to Wigan after the Warriors...
 

starlynVR

Guest
MATT JOBSON ???????????????

THE LIST GOES ON AND ON [/B]

LOL!!! Dats pretty funny, Matt Jobson's a jobber.. Whats going on! Its Justin Morgan all over again!!:confused:
 

starlynVR

Guest
Like some have said, its a pretty big list! -

Justin Morgan...
Scott Coxon??? - What on earth were they thinking??
Paul Staladi???
Brady Malam!?!?
Matt Jobson - Now that justs makes me laugh because our current management opted to pick up this jobber!
Andy Platt...

It never ends!!!
 

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
754
Esoj_old
Replies
29
Views
2K
Ronnie_7_old
Replies
7
Views
862
BigD_old
ShaunJohnson7
Replies
38
Views
2K
Swanley
Swanley
Replies
58
Views
5K
fanrrior_old

Last Game

08 May

10 - 29
3.9 Total Avg Rating
2.2 Your Avg Rating

Highest Rated Player

Lowest Rated Player

Compiled from 13 ratings