Not only did he not resign him at the Warriors.....Nafe is now signed with the Roosters for the rest of this season and next season.....he got the Cleary punt again?????
To be fair he wasn't a regular before Ivan came to the club.. Apparently he was weak on defence for them, and the Panthers fans aren't to fussed, but see he has potential. They have Seg for next year, who looks like a mega gun imo. Cowboys cant keep all their upcoming stars I guess.
Do we need Nafe back? On what Mara showed for us, no. Good luck to him, would love to see a few more Kiwi Hookers around
Pardon my ignorance, but I can't see how "Nafe Seluini has signed for the Roosters" equates to "Ivan Cleary doesn't like Nafe Seluini".
Can someone who holds to this view please expand on the logic behind it?
Alternatively we could call fanrrior in to explain the logical fallacy used.
Well, yes. But the issue extends beyond that - the Warriors offered Seluini a pre-season contract which he turned down, signing a longer deal with the Panthers instead.
A degree of factual integrity would go a long way, methinks.
Pardon my ignorance, but I can't see how "Nafe Seluini has signed for the Roosters" equates to "Ivan Cleary doesn't like Nafe Seluini".
Can someone who holds to this view please expand on the logic behind it?
Seluini did the right thing turning down training contract...When Heremaia,Hohaia,Mara,Berrigan,Godinet,Brown was on the books
There isn't any logic behind it. Though the thread remained as Nafe's career is still of interest to some. The OP won't be one we'll be promoting, putting it nicely...
post hoc, ergo hoc fallacy. One makes the mistake of assuming correlation implies causation...Alternatively we could call fanrrior in to explain the logical fallacy used.
Yeah, I can almost imagine a scenario where the Panthers win the wooden spoon and Cleary gets sacked - I don't expect the latter to happen as he's rebuilding the club, but still - and then I can make a thread entitled "Brown doesn't like Cleary", in which I point out that Ivan Cleary left the Warriors to go to the Panthers while Lewis Brown was here (and thus player power sent him on his way). Then Brown went to the Panthers, and Cleary got pushed out again, thus Cleary is a victim of Downtown Lewis Brown. I'd probably try to add in a witty reference to Brown's nickname "Snatch" to further 'strengthen' my point.
Meh...sorry.
27 Sep
Compiled from 19 ratings