Spence
Sgt. Pepper
I'll come back to this in the off-season - too many variables. Namely how Hurrell develops, what is happening with Inu and whether or not Godinet gets any extended time in the halves this year.
Lord Gnome of Howick MBE
I
I'd still like to see Inu on the wing, but that aint gonna happen after last week's shambles (and the re-signing of Lil' Bill.)
I'd still like to see Inu on the wing, but that aint gonna happen after last week's shambles (and the re-signing of Lil' Bill.)
MarkW
I think Carlos will end up being the No.6 but I reckon Bluey will want a more experienced head in there to start with.
Leuluai will be a very good utility option though, much like Hohaia but a better playmaker.
I'm also working on the premise that Inu will be released.
Eva
I'd like to see Collier get a run later on this year and/or next year. I liked him in the U20's and from what I've seen in the Vulcan's he's still good, plus we need someone to replace Maloney with our conversions.
I'd go:
1. Fisiiahi - since I prefer him over Locke
2. Collier
3. Nielsen
4. Benry/Hurrel
5. Vatuvei
6. Tuimavave
7. Johnson
14. Leuluai
I agree with the comments of thinking Bluey may prefer a more experienced player at 6 to start with, but I hope that Tuimavave gets some game time at 6 and builds on a first grade pairing with Johnson. It'd be good to have two young halves that have been playing together for a while and will be the future of the club. With players like Collier and Nielsen in the team, if the Fish is injured during a game, Collier can move to FB, Nielsen to Wing and Captain Mannering/Tuimavave to center, Leuluai is cover for the halves. It would mean a bit of reshuffling but that way they could have Leuluai on the bench with a 3 forward/prop bench.
I'd go:
1. Fisiiahi - since I prefer him over Locke
2. Collier
3. Nielsen
4. Benry/Hurrel
5. Vatuvei
6. Tuimavave
7. Johnson
14. Leuluai
I agree with the comments of thinking Bluey may prefer a more experienced player at 6 to start with, but I hope that Tuimavave gets some game time at 6 and builds on a first grade pairing with Johnson. It'd be good to have two young halves that have been playing together for a while and will be the future of the club. With players like Collier and Nielsen in the team, if the Fish is injured during a game, Collier can move to FB, Nielsen to Wing and Captain Mannering/Tuimavave to center, Leuluai is cover for the halves. It would mean a bit of reshuffling but that way they could have Leuluai on the bench with a 3 forward/prop bench.
Lord Gnome of Howick MBE
22 BEAST
Blain
I thought Collier was a Luke Covell for the Juniors.. Solid, kicks goals and thats all. Has a bit of size but I never saw him use it well enough to be considered for higher honours. Fish is ahead of him easily anyway. I would love to see;
Locke
Tupou
Nielson
Hurrell
Vatuvei
TL
Shaun Johnson
That left edge could demolish sides.. Shaun Johnson running it out wide to Hurrell who busts 2 tackles to put Manu over in the corner? Yes Please. Will nned to develop a good defence combo to work though.
Locke
Tupou
Nielson
Hurrell
Vatuvei
TL
Shaun Johnson
That left edge could demolish sides.. Shaun Johnson running it out wide to Hurrell who busts 2 tackles to put Manu over in the corner? Yes Please. Will nned to develop a good defence combo to work though.
ToiletDuck
Administrator
Most of the backline picks itself (at this point). The main question is who will be the other centre...and will Henry stay in the backline or be moved to the backrow? The club will obviously be hoping Hurrell develops into a consistent first grade centre by the end of this season, and with Inu (likely) on the way out - will probably re-sign Ropati as depth.
Fazz
HOW COULD ANYBODY? Not to be a dick, but I would just like to see some sort of justification for thinking Fish is anywhere in Locke's universe. From what we saw in his games this year Fish can't defend, doesn't bother with kick returns, and was a non event in attack...
Tuimavave is coasting on his form from 2 years ago tbh. He's been either injured or just slightly above average all year and most of last. Certainly his form doesn't justify giving him the first shot over an international in TL. That said, a lot can happen in one off season and we may well see TL playing the bench utility.
¿N. ig-mah¿
I find this very hard to believe.
I personally can't even find room in the extended squad for the Fish. I will be very upset if the announcement comes that we have lost Omar. I believe Omar should be our first choice winger along with Manu and our backup Fullback. He has incredible defence in the U20s. Naturally he won't be as strong defensively in first grade, but a strong junior defence is at least a good start, and from what I have seen any defence is better than Fish's limp attempts. I would be using Tupou as depth on the wing in case of injury to Manu or Omar (or injury to Locke with Omar shifting back). I would frankly be happy if the club released Fish to sign Omar.
Fazz
Spot on. Omar has a massive upside, not only on field but off as well. He's hugely marketable to the Arab population as he'd be one of very few in the NRL. Could be massive in the future if he's even close to the player he's been in the U20s...
Sebastian
1. Locke
2. Tupou (Competition may win out, but at the moment he's a safe option that's steadily improving.)
3. Nielsen (Owns his spot but as Benry has Browns spot, he'll always be a good back up should Nielsen go down.)
4. Hurrell (This shouldn't be up for debate. Honestly, he's got potential to be our best centre ever.)
5. Vatuvei (Manu may be replaced at some time, possibly next season. Which would bring, Omar, Inu or whoever is next off the rank into play.)
6. Godinet - Leuluai - Tuimavave (This needs an off season to sort out, as all three have strong points.)
7. Johnson
Just like to say i hope we manage to keep who we want in our current outside back collection. I'm a lover of depth. Though not knowing the next crop of young blood so early, new stars will always emerge.
2. Tupou (Competition may win out, but at the moment he's a safe option that's steadily improving.)
3. Nielsen (Owns his spot but as Benry has Browns spot, he'll always be a good back up should Nielsen go down.)
4. Hurrell (This shouldn't be up for debate. Honestly, he's got potential to be our best centre ever.)
5. Vatuvei (Manu may be replaced at some time, possibly next season. Which would bring, Omar, Inu or whoever is next off the rank into play.)
6. Godinet - Leuluai - Tuimavave (This needs an off season to sort out, as all three have strong points.)
7. Johnson
Just like to say i hope we manage to keep who we want in our current outside back collection. I'm a lover of depth. Though not knowing the next crop of young blood so early, new stars will always emerge.
Lord Gnome of Howick MBE
1. Locke.............no contest
2. Tupou............finally showed he can finish like an NRL winger
3. Henry.............if he's this good after 9 games, how good will he be after a whole season, better than Nielson I'll bet.
4. Hurrell............his defense was vastly improved vs the Bronc's, again, by next season he could be anything.
5. Fissiahi/Inu.....both have the ability, but are both too stupid or too lazy to get close to their potential, lets hope one of them can pull their heads outa their asses.
6. Tuimavave/Ropati.....a 6 who plays like a tight center will be perfect running off Shaun Johnson next season, Godinet or TL will be a step backwards IMO.
7. Johnson..........with Maloney gone, there will be no more taking a back seat to the so called senior half, next year we'll see exactly what he can do.
Neilson and TL are depth players only, good solid depth no doubt, but injury cover none the less.
2. Tupou............finally showed he can finish like an NRL winger
3. Henry.............if he's this good after 9 games, how good will he be after a whole season, better than Nielson I'll bet.
4. Hurrell............his defense was vastly improved vs the Bronc's, again, by next season he could be anything.
5. Fissiahi/Inu.....both have the ability, but are both too stupid or too lazy to get close to their potential, lets hope one of them can pull their heads outa their asses.
6. Tuimavave/Ropati.....a 6 who plays like a tight center will be perfect running off Shaun Johnson next season, Godinet or TL will be a step backwards IMO.
7. Johnson..........with Maloney gone, there will be no more taking a back seat to the so called senior half, next year we'll see exactly what he can do.
Neilson and TL are depth players only, good solid depth no doubt, but injury cover none the less.
