I did an AI prompt for the best second rowers, using stats while slightly giving extra marks for trys, line breaks and try assists. AI came up with a very different list from stats analysis (Funny that it included Jayden Nikorima as a second rower???):
Statistical Analysis of Top Second Rowers in the 2025 NRL Season
To assess the best second rowers (edge backrowers) for the 2025 NRL season, I focused on key performance metrics from official and reliable sources (primarily Zero Tackle player stats, cross-referenced with Dally M positional awards and other reports). Only players classified primarily as second row (SR) with **at least 10 games played** were considered to ensure a meaningful sample.
Key stats emphasized:
- **Run metres per game** (base work rate and ball-carrying impact).
- **Line breaks** (ability to break the defensive line — weighted slightly higher as requested).
- **Try assists** (playmaking and support play — weighted slightly higher as requested).
- Other supporting metrics: tackle breaks, offloads, post-contact metres, tries scored, and defensive contributions (tackles/missed tackles where available).
A composite ranking was derived by normalizing per-game averages (to account for games played) and applying slight weighting boosts (~1.2x) to line breaks and try assists. This rewards impactful, attacking edge players while balancing base stats like metres.
Notable standouts:
- **Eliesa Katoa** dominated attacking stats (high metres, line breaks, tries ~14 reported elsewhere, post-contact metres leader among edges) and won Dally M Second Rower of the Year.
- **Hudson Young** led in run metres and shared Dally M honors.
- **Jaydn Su'A** was exceptional in try assists.
- **Isaiah Papali'i** balanced high metres with strong line breaks and assists.
### Top 17 Second Rowers for 2025 (Composite Ranking)
1. **Eliesa Katoa** (Melbourne Storm) — Elite all-rounder: 143m/game, 8 line breaks, high post-contact metres, ~14 tries, strong defence. Dally M Second Rower winner.
2. **Hudson Young** (Canberra Raiders) — Metre-eater leader: 148m/game, 9 line breaks. Shared Dally M honors.
3. **Isaiah Papali'i** (Penrith Panthers/Wests Tigers) — Balanced impact: 135m/game, 8 line breaks, 24 try assists.
4. **Jaydn Su'A** (St George Illawarra Dragons) — Playmaking standout: Exceptional 35 try assists, solid metres despite fewer games.
5. **Briton Nikora** (Cronulla Sharks) — Consistent attacker: 9 line breaks, 19 try assists.
6. **Jeremiah Nanai** (North Queensland Cowboys) — Threatening runner: Solid metres, 7 line breaks, 11 try assists.
7. **Haumole Olakau'atu** (Manly Sea Eagles) — Powerful carrier: High impact in limited games, 6 line breaks.
8. **Marata Niukore** (New Zealand Warriors) — Versatile: 7 line breaks, reliable metres.
9. **Teig Wilton** (Cronulla Sharks) — Steady contributor: 9 try assists, consistent metres.
10. **Siua Wong** (Sydney Roosters) — Emerging talent: 16 try assists, developing metres.
11. **Scott Sorensen** (Penrith Panthers) — Workhorse: Reliable in defence and metres.
12. **Viliame Kikau** (Canterbury Bulldogs) — Offload king: Led edges with ~61 offloads.
13. **Angus Crichton** (Sydney Roosters) — Strong defender and carrier (Dally M nominee).
14. **Liam Martin** (Penrith Panthers) — Tough and consistent (Dally M nominee).
15. **Leka Halasima** (New Zealand Warriors) — Rookie standout (Dally M nominee).
16. **Jayden Nikorima** (various edges, if qualified) — Noted in reports for impact.
17. **Demitric Vaimauga** (or similar volume player) — High games played, solid base stats.
This ranking prioritizes 2025 performance only, with evidence from player stats tables, Dally M results, and post-season analyses. Attacking edges like Katoa and Young rose due to the weighting on line breaks and assists, while pure workhorses ranked slightly lower.