Kiwis Treatment Of Marshall Is Appalling

The treatment of former Kiwis captain Benji Marshall by coach Stephen Kearney and the Kiwis is appalling.

They have belittled one of the best Kiwi players to have played for the side in the past decade by refusing to select him when every other international player has fallen over injured. It has gone beyond a coach not picking a guy due to a lack of form – this is a personal decision surely.

Kiwis starters Shaun Johnson, Kieran Foran and Thomas Leuluai are unavailable for the three-test tour of England due to injury. Instead of selecting Marshall, who featured prominently on the Dally M NRL Player of the Year leader board earlier in the week, Kearney has opted to pick rookies, players that haven’t even played first grade let alone international football and will play players out of position rather than pick the former Golden Boot winner.

What message does that send to Marshall? Kearney will talk about blooding players for the future and I support him in doing that but to a degree. To select players like Te Maire Martin, Manaia Cherrington, Matt McIllwrick, Kodi Nikorima and Tuimoala Lolohea – players that have either not played first grade, not played in the halves in first grade or have only a handful of experience there ahead of a guy who was a candidate to be named the NRL’s best player in 2015 is Kearney completely thumbing his nose at Marshall. If you want to blood young players – would there be a better role model for them in the squad than Marshall?

Marshall captained his country – led them to a Four Nations title and played a significant role in the 2008 World Cup victory. This is the thanks he gets for his troubles.

The Kiwis have worked hard to build a reputation that sees them rightly be called the best team in the world. But this sort of petty carry on is not a good look.

Kearney’s Kiwis better win the three-test series in England otherwise he will have some serious explaining to do.
About author
This article has been written by Dale Budge. Dale is a well known rugby league commentator and journalist, having covered the sport for over 10 years.

Website : playtheball.co.nz
Twitter : @playtheball

Comments

Dignity and Class, I heard Jason describe Kearney's behaviour over your Marshall fiasco with these two words on radiosports today. Quite well put I thought, unlike your behaviour on this matter which resembles a dog with a bone. Typical of a media driven witch-hunt. May I remind you the results aren't in yet let alone the whistle for kick-off blown.
 
Dignity and Class, I heard Jason describe Kearney's behaviour over your Marshall fiasco with these two words on radiosports today. Quite well put I thought, unlike your behaviour on this matter which resembles a dog with a bone. Typical of a media driven witch-hunt. May I remind you the results aren't in yet let alone the whistle for kick-off blown.
Someone described Kearney as having class and dignity with how he has handled this Marshall issue? Really? Were they drunk? Care to explain how Kearney's behavour is befitting of someone having dignity and class?
 
Dignity and Class, I heard Jason describe Kearney's behaviour over your Marshall fiasco with these two words on radiosports today. Quite well put I thought, unlike your behaviour on this matter which resembles a dog with a bone. Typical of a media driven witch-hunt. May I remind you the results aren't in yet let alone the whistle for kick-off blown.
Sure, let explain briefly. Budge was guesting today on Kent's radiosport show, Jason a regular caller made the comments as part of his opinion. Obviously not having heard the conversation you will be missing a lot of the context of the comments but you can always listen to the recording online here 2:45 in http://content.radionetwork.co.nz/weekondemand/radiosport/61430.mp3
 
I have an opinion - that doesn't mean I have no class. It appears to be the view of the majority from what I can gather. The results ARE in - Marshall wasn't selected in the train-on squad. Now, Kearney has no halves with ANY test experience to choose from because he has a personal issue with Marshall. You think Marshall isn't worthy as one of NZ's top 6 halves despite finishing in a tie for second in the Dally M NRL player of the year voting??
No witch hunt here pal - just questioning the most unexplained non-selection in Kiwis league history.
 
Dignity and Class, I heard Jason describe Kearney's behaviour over your Marshall fiasco with these two words on radiosports today. Quite well put I thought, unlike your behaviour on this matter which resembles a dog with a bone. Typical of a media driven witch-hunt. May I remind you the results aren't in yet let alone the whistle for kick-off blown.
And you'll note that Jason put forward some good thoughts and I acknowledged his points. It doesn't change my view but I take his point. He attacked my argument not me as person as you seem to want to do at every opportunity.
 
Dignity and Class, I heard Jason describe Kearney's behaviour over your Marshall fiasco with these two words on radiosports today. Quite well put I thought, unlike your behaviour on this matter which resembles a dog with a bone. Typical of a media driven witch-hunt. May I remind you the results aren't in yet let alone the whistle for kick-off blown.
Agreed, you did acknowledge those good points. Perhaps I could have said things differently, however I stand by my beliefs and still feel your article's were poor and I challenged you to do better, attacking you personally wasn't my intention but if you put yourself out there then expect to cop some flak once in a while.
 
Dignity and Class, I heard Jason describe Kearney's behaviour over your Marshall fiasco with these two words on radiosports today. Quite well put I thought, unlike your behaviour on this matter which resembles a dog with a bone. Typical of a media driven witch-hunt. May I remind you the results aren't in yet let alone the whistle for kick-off blown.
BTW you're publishing and promoting yourself as a journalist here on our forum so you better grow some thick skin. I was a foundation OneTribe member, Red jacket 1st 50 and all, in the whole time I've never seen anyone promote themselves as you do, a mark of good journalism is to illuminate as opposed to trying to achieve a result. Which are you?
 
Dignity and Class, I heard Jason describe Kearney's behaviour over your Marshall fiasco with these two words on radiosports today. Quite well put I thought, unlike your behaviour on this matter which resembles a dog with a bone. Typical of a media driven witch-hunt. May I remind you the results aren't in yet let alone the whistle for kick-off blown.
I have no problem copping flak - i cop it all the time and it goes hand in hand with having an opinion and putting it out there. Attack my argument as much as you like - I actually enjoy being challenged. Anyone that knows me would know that too by the way. Good on you for supporting your team and the sport - you'll never hear me criticise that.
 
Dignity and Class, I heard Jason describe Kearney's behaviour over your Marshall fiasco with these two words on radiosports today. Quite well put I thought, unlike your behaviour on this matter which resembles a dog with a bone. Typical of a media driven witch-hunt. May I remind you the results aren't in yet let alone the whistle for kick-off blown.
Not promoting myself here - I'm simply a fan offering my own views on the game i enjoy. The moderators chose to automatically publish my articles on the site. I've worked for most of NZ's major media outlets at one time or other - if i was about getting profile I would have chosen different career options. I'm essentially a stay-at-home Dad first and foremost these days and am fortunate to earn a full-time living whilst doing that. I started my little blogsite as a hobby
 
Dignity and Class, I heard Jason describe Kearney's behaviour over your Marshall fiasco with these two words on radiosports today. Quite well put I thought, unlike your behaviour on this matter which resembles a dog with a bone. Typical of a media driven witch-hunt. May I remind you the results aren't in yet let alone the whistle for kick-off blown.
It's your name at the bottom of the article along with a synopsis and links to your website and twitter. How is that not self promotion? You could have stayed an alias person with a forum handle just like the rest of us fans, aye.
 
Dignity and Class, I heard Jason describe Kearney's behaviour over your Marshall fiasco with these two words on radiosports today. Quite well put I thought, unlike your behaviour on this matter which resembles a dog with a bone. Typical of a media driven witch-hunt. May I remind you the results aren't in yet let alone the whistle for kick-off blown.
Sorry but I'm not responsible for that - speak to the administrators. I am putting my name to my articles on my own website. What gets pulled onto this site is not up to me. I post on the forum here like anyone else - I'm no different at all and don't profess to be. There are plenty of people that are more involved in the club or the sport than I am - I've been made aware of that since posting on here.
 
Dignity and Class, I heard Jason describe Kearney's behaviour over your Marshall fiasco with these two words on radiosports today. Quite well put I thought, unlike your behaviour on this matter which resembles a dog with a bone. Typical of a media driven witch-hunt. May I remind you the results aren't in yet let alone the whistle for kick-off blown.
Cool, you have my apologies if you want them. I however want a robust and constructive debate with you not bloody argument. I will respect you but always challenge you if I see fit, hopefully I do that without stepping over the line. I respect your effort for what its worth.
 
Dignity and Class, I heard Jason describe Kearney's behaviour over your Marshall fiasco with these two words on radiosports today. Quite well put I thought, unlike your behaviour on this matter which resembles a dog with a bone. Typical of a media driven witch-hunt. May I remind you the results aren't in yet let alone the whistle for kick-off blown.
Mate - I'm more than happy for robust debate - I like it and enjoy it. Have a crack at my opinions any time you like. To clarify i post in the forum here like anyone else. The articles section stuff that appears has been set up by the admins to appear from my site whenever I write a new piece. I'm all for that but that is their choice not me pushing my profile.
 
Dignity and Class, I heard Jason describe Kearney's behaviour over your Marshall fiasco with these two words on radiosports today. Quite well put I thought, unlike your behaviour on this matter which resembles a dog with a bone. Typical of a media driven witch-hunt. May I remind you the results aren't in yet let alone the whistle for kick-off blown.
I can confirm that I asked Play The Ball to have his articles on here (as i did with numerous other journalists/media personalities who frequent the site). The only stipulation was that in return he engage with the fans on here. There is no self promotion from him at all, and im sure the general consensus on here is that its a breath of fresh air having him on here providing a very unique perspective.

As always, the rule of this site is to play the ball, not the ball. Quite apt in this regard.
 
I have an opinion - that doesn't mean I have no class. It appears to be the view of the majority from what I can gather. The results ARE in - Marshall wasn't selected in the train-on squad. Now, Kearney has no halves with ANY test experience to choose from because he has a personal issue with Marshall. You think Marshall isn't worthy as one of NZ's top 6 halves despite finishing in a tie for second in the Dally M NRL player of the year voting??
No witch hunt here pal - just questioning the most unexplained non-selection in Kiwis league history.
From what I have read on the Forums here, the problems are with Benji and the playing group(including injured players). If the information is correct(look at int forum.), then I completely back Kearney not selecting Marshall EVER again.
 

Article information

Author
Play The Ball
Views
2,502
Mod Notes
15
Last update

More in International Game

More from Play The Ball

Top Bottom